PI – OVERVIEW AND FEEDBACK – Part 2
Traders,
Continued from PI – Overview and Feedback.
Click here to watch the video on youtube. We will soon have a dedicated section on Z-Connect for Pi to help you understand all features and functionality.
We are probably 3 to 4 weeks away from the final release of Pi, and thanks to all of you who are helping us test this out. 1300 suggestions/comments and all your emails, is an incredible response, Thanks a ton!
Wanted to let you all know things which we intend to be ready with before our final release. A lot of what you all have requested for are features, our initial goal is to make sure everything that is available till now works well especially trading related, and we will keep adding all your requests in due course of time.
Pi is a trading platform that also has advanced charting, backtesting, and many other functions. It has to constantly communicate with exchanges both to send and receive data. I don’t think it will be fair to compare this with any standalone charting software available in the market like AmiBroker, MetaStock, and others, in terms of features, data usage, or nimbleness.
We have done a fair bit of fixes in the last couple of months, and delayed on the final release because of roadblocks that we hadn’t expected earlier. All the feature requests in terms of new indicators, more drawing tools, pivots, crosshairs, adding option calculators, and many others are all noted down. Few of these like not being able to change color for all the three lines on Bollinger bands or not being able to remove the volume section on a chart, etc., are I guess things that you expect by default, but we had to prioritize and we have decided to first work on things that are most important for trading.
For the final release, here are the things pending:
- We are waiting for our data server to go live, so that we could give you historical charts with no missing data. We are also planning an advanced data streaming solution within a month from when Pi is released which should also make it the fastest platform in terms of speed of update of quotes. Once done, the bandwidth utilization also would reduce significantly.
- The above will also allow you to see daily charts, which is presently missing.
- Trading on all exchanges have been enabled now, MCX trading will be available on Pi from next week.
- Taking Bracket orders live.
- Getting the Pi bridge live for AmiBroker and Metatrader for semi-automated trading. You can have strategies run on Ami/Meta, which can generate buy/sell orders on Pi.
- Presently, you can see the actual average buying/selling price for both open positions and holdings. A few bugs still exist on this, we will have those fixed soon.
- Certain actions like double clicking on snap quote are causing Pi to slow down, these issues will be fixed.
- Saving and loading work spaces.
- Putting up a help video and Z-Connect blog posts on all aspects of trading using Pi.
- Getting all your TradeScript coding related queries answered on TradingQ&A.
- If quick login is not enabled, it takes some time to login. Having this issue fixed.
- Fixing tiny trading related issues that are still prevalent.
- Small little fixes that are still pending in the UI.
- Taking your feedback on trading related issues/improvements and having them fixed.
After the final release, we will start working on all the feature requests that we have received until now. Do continue posting suggestions and requests if not posted already here.
Happy Trading,
Nithin Kamath
CEO @ Zerodha and partnering startups through Rainmatter to help grow and improve the capital market ecosystem in India. Love playing poker, basketball, and guitar. @Nithin0dha on Twitter. | Personal website: https://nithinkamath.me
how to get zerodha pi software
Check out on top of the blogpost, there is a survey link. Fill it up and send an email to [email protected]. He will have this enabled.
Dear Nithin,
Appreciate your great effort for Pi,
Is there any possibilities for Basket Order in Pi and would like link Market Watch to MS Excel.
Thanks,
Both of these are currently not available.
Presently both basket and link to excel not working .we will have it up after the final release .
hi nitin, I am long wait this kind of software, thank u for pi, we are looking for, where price alerts of list stock can be taken from excel sheet. if that option includes it will be great. thank u
Nithin, any update on when basket orders will be available through Pi ? I am waiting for this kind of functionality since a long time.
HI, Nitin, wish you very happy n profitable new year, pls advise where is link for pi platform, i am not getting it on top.
We are going to be putting up the latest beta release out in the next 10 days, we will share the link with you then.
Hi, when pi software will be released as 1st week is over
pls advise where is link for pi platform, i am not getting it on top.
Dear Nitin Sir,
I would be great if we have darvas box Indicator which was available earlier in Nest version. I would be great that darvas box indicator is available in PI.
RECENTLY….pi is really become cause for losses due sudden failure of software especially during evening critical hours.
whosoever is concerned really need to fix it asap.
dear sir,
Are given below analysis and indicators available in pi software-
Pasavento & Fibnacci analysis
Ergodic
Advance Camrilla levels
Gann 9 levels & Analysis
Eliot wave Analysis
if not, can U add above mentioned things in Pi? .
thnks
Not right now, but we will add this after our final release.
DEAR NITHIN,
PI IS WONDERFUL EXPERIENCE . MORE THAN EXPECTED .THANKS
PLS ADD FEATURES LIKE SUPPORT RESISTANCE LEVEL .SMALL DELAY FEEL WHILE ORDER PLACING AND EXECUTING .
GREAT THANKS
Yes, should improve before the final release.
Hi Nirhin,
I am not able to login to pi after server upgrade. It says server not available. I have the latest version installed which is available in Q. Please help.
Regards
Vinay
Vinay, a few things have changed due to the update. If you are not enabled on NSE, BSE, and MCX, you will not be able to login currently. We are working on having a new release out asap with this fix.
Hi Nithin,
FYI, I have access to all the exchanges. Still i am getting this issue. Please note i have currently v1.0.0.4.
Vinay, If you can give us time till this weekend, we will have the new release up by monday.
Hi Nitin,
Are there any plans for having Ichimoku Cloud & Supertrend charts available in Pi?
Thanks
Yeah, but once we have our final release.
Hello, since i cannot upload multiple images, i have posted feedback on traderji. My problem is with the charts. I’m sure as a trader you will understand the problem. http://www.traderji.com/brokers-trading-platforms/95838-feedback-pi-beta-7.html#post1034824
Chetan, will look into it. But I had answered this earlier, check this. If you check the same chart, across 3 or 4 platforms, you will find difference. But will look into this again, I have access to esignal, let me compare with those charts .
sir any charges for pi software
Nope. The best things in life come free 🙂
NITHIN
sir i made a request earlier for pi as my ZT is not running properly …the issue is that it gets hanged every 20- 30 minutes once i open 1 or 2 charts … or else it is running fine … zerodha support members have looked into the issue multiple times but not able to solve … they say omneseys technical team will contact me and that has not yet happened …. so please do something about it …
one member told me that you are giving pi according to batches and only when my batch number comes i will be allotted pi… sir due to the issue with ZT could you please send me pi , as i have not been able to trade since the last 10 days now ….
client id–DK0983
thankyou
(sorry for saying this on a public forum about the ZT problem … i hope you will understand)
Karan, we are very near to the final release of Pi, when we will give it out for everyone. But if you have already requested, you should get it tomorrow.
id – DK0983
i know you have been keeping a bit busy due to updates .. but this problem is serious with me.
1. my NEST TRADER hangs after running for half an hour …
2. none i mean NONE of your support members are able to solve this issue , not even the technical team…
3. it has been 2 WEEKS like this and i have not traded…
4. i m extremely fed up
5. i have sent mails to support as well but they say sorry sir please continue using nest … arre yaar when the system is not running properly then how can i use it…
6. last monday i sent a mail requesting Pi , but till now i have not got it …i have requested 3or 4 times now… i’m not asking for pi because i cannot wait or anything like that, but because my NEST is not RUNNING properly … so i thought that this problem will not be there with Pi … i could easily trade ….
7. last sunday u said i will get pi by tomorrow but i’m still waiting….
PLEASE do something about it….
thankyou
(i’m enclosing 2 pictures of nest trader being hanged everytime i run it for 20-30 minutes)
Karan, we did a server upgrade over the last weekend, which changed a bunch of things, hence the delay in giving you access to Pi. Give us time till next week, we will give you an installation. ABout NEST, let me get someone from our team to call and have this checked asap.
Hi sir,
Will the pi work smoothly on Asus eeebook x205 with Intel atom soc with 2 gb ram… Plz update.. Also, is pi compatible with Windows 10? Expecting your reply at the soonest
Pi works well with windows 10. Can’t comment on that particular model.
Sir, plz tell me whether atom processor will be OK for pi to run smoothly… Consider our old netbooks… With atom processor and 2 gigs of ram
If the processor is dual core, it should be fine.
Nitin Sir, please give some more information about Pi bridge….thanks
The bridge will let you connect Ami, Meta, Ninja trader to Pi. We will make it such a way that you can connect any front end of yours to PI, and use Pi for sending orders to the exchange. So if you have a strategy on Ami, which gives a buy signal, this can either be semi automated to send an order or completely automated. We are almost done with Ami, and we will put a video on using it soon.
Sir, Will we need to pay some fees for using PiBridge….Also I have sent request for required dll file…will be great to see log files…)
Thanks
Hey Nithin thanks for prompt response on earlier query.
Login is failing with Server unavailable..any issue with servers? What is the likely downtime? Will it be available over the weekend
Thanks
Neo
Neo, we upgraded our servers yesterday. We have put up a new release of PI in Q, you will have to uninstall the current and intall the new one to be able to use Pi.
The latest version (07/12) is failing to launch with error “Unhandled exception has occured…”
Issue seems to be resolved now. Able to login.
Again appreciate quick resolution
How this problem of “Unhandled Exception…” was sorted out, I am still getting the same…
Desperately waiting for PI….yeeee
Please confirm that you will have charts on Nifty Future values as well as Nifty Spot values.
Yep, it is already available, Nifty and Banknifty spot index.
Dear Nithin
Net change & Net change indicator is missing from MARKET WATCH, Please add these two columns.
Have u installed the latest release? We have added net change already.
Yes, Please add Net change indicator also
Thanks
The latest version (07/12) is failing to launch with error “Unhandled exception has occured…”
Hi,
After updation of PI i am having login error with message ”Unhandled exception has occured…”
Attach is the print screen for your reference
Guys, looks like your password has a special character. This is something we are working on getting fixed. Can you change the password using NEST (without special characters) and then try logging in.
Sir i am going to open an account on zerodha and i got information zerodha provide mobile TA software for trading. without TA (technical analysis) software i am not interested to join in Zerodha and i want to use on Mobile and computer both. In office hrs i unable to trade with computer and that time i only can use Mobile.Share khan provide a beautiful TA software for Mobile as well as computer. can i get and use PI software on my mobile also ???
No Pi, won’t work on mobile. You will have to use our mobile app for that.
But is ur mobile app provide technical charts (1 mint,hourly and day ) with indicators??if not than plz confirm me sir …
I too also getting PI login error after installing latest version (07/12) today.
thanks
Guys, looks like your password has a special character. This is something we are working on getting fixed. Can you change the password using NEST (without special characters) and then try logging in.
Dear Nithin
I am using only Alpha and numeric characters, no special characters.
Before update the password worked fine, after latest update I am getting this error, before update and after latest update the password is same.
thanks
Yes, the upgrade of our servers at the backend changed a few things which we hadn’t anticipated. We will have a new release of Pi asap. This issue is coming for all those people using Pi who are not enabled on any one of the exchanges (so for example if you are not enabled on MCX). This issue is not coming if you have all exchanges enabled with us.
Dear Nithin
Now the PI is able to open upto here and getting error at this place with same alpha and numeric password.
thanks.
i am also getting the same error..my password does not contain any special character it has only char and numeric
Yes, the upgrade of our servers at the backend changed a few things which we hadn’t anticipated. We will have a new release of Pi asap. This issue is coming for all those people using Pi who are not enabled on any one of the exchanges (so for example if you are not enabled on MCX). This issue is not coming if you have all exchanges enabled with us.
hey nitin,
1.when market index will be uploaded like nifty, bank nifty, cnx it ? ex- i means if i select NIFTY , then all 50 stock i can see.
2. i have some strategies which are not based on TA, i need LIVE data in excel to generate signal. how can i do so?
thanks for creating PI
1. Soon
2. Soon.
Sir is ur mobile trading software provide Candlestick chart( minute,hourly and daily) with indicators and drawing facility??
The current one has very basic candlestick chart. We are looking at launching something soon with indicators
what’s up with Pi this morning? getting error message “unable to connect to remote server” . Reinstalled the latest release
Yes, the upgrade of our servers at the backend changed a few things which we hadn’t anticipated. We will have a new release of Pi asap. This issue is coming for all those people using Pi who are not enabled on any one of the exchanges (so for example if you are not enabled on MCX). This issue is not coming if you have all exchanges enabled with us
Pi doesn’t work, trade.zerodha.com does not work, ZT doesn’t work. and customer care full buys.
What the hell you are maintaining uptime?
It is bad week start for all, must be
Jnyanesh we did a server upgrade over the weekend. We had sent email and sms regarding this, http://zerodha.com/critical-update/. If you have done this update, ZT should work fine. We have had issues with web and mobile app, and our customer care lines are clogged today.
Mobile app download link broken. Please fix asap.
yes, looking at it.
Please fix this link sir,
http://trade.zerodha.com/AppDownload/servlet/download
Desktop sw is not blocked in office.
Z5 is not working for my id dn0939
Phone line always busy.
Launching Pi gives an error message ..The remote server returned an error(503). Server Unavailable.
Not able to trade since then, Please resolve it ASAP
Yes, the upgrade of our servers at the backend changed a few things which we hadn’t anticipated. We will have a new release of Pi asap.
Why is NEST trader not working even after downloading the CRITICAL updates ??? Also why is your customer service not picking up the phone. I am facing this issue of the Customer service executives not picking up the phone from the past 4 weeks.
Even today since Nest trader, is not working i had an open postion which i had to close, but no repsonse for my calls.
This is now getting out of hand.
http://zerodha.com/critical-update/ , if you are facing issue uninstall and install the latest version http://zerodha.com/zt. Today, our phone lines got clogged with all the excess phone calls, so ringing even though you are in queue. This should be sorted by end of day.
http://zerodha.com/critical-update/ , if you are facing issue uninstall and install the latest version http://zerodha.com/zt. Today, our phone lines got clogged with all the excess phone calls because of this update, so ringing even though you are in queue. There was no problem with NEST, we had issues with our web/mobile app. Everything should be fixed tonight.
NIthin Sir
I Am New in Zerodha I Had Open A Account Since 2 Week Ago How To Download Zerodha Pi platform
This is still in beta, we will put the final release soon. You can send a request to us by clicking here: https://docs.google.com/a/zerodha.com/forms/d/15hHNIwg5N5rBvqc_8X6Sl6jBgcP-shVC8r6XPnV-hEo/viewform
Not able to Login to ZT nor Pi
trade.zerodha.com is also not working
We had sent this over the last week: http://zerodha.com/critical-update/. You had to run the update.
For Pi, the upgrade of our servers at the backend changed a few things which we hadn’t anticipated. We will have a new release of Pi asap.
Today is the worst day for Zerodha. Not able to login through any one the ways.. ZT or ZTmobile or PI or web…. Usually, the customer service is excellent but today.. there is no reply.
Atleast you can inform us what is going on?… Please update whats the status of the fixes….
something really wrong nothing works.
Customer care full time busy, not even able to connect.
Zerodha not even aware of the issue, they say everything is fine.
Not able to place or trade anything
Worst……!!
Nitin, are you looking into this. Do you own the issue?
My ZT is working okay. After downloading the December 4 critical update I couldn’t install it myself as when you double-click on it , Windows asks which program you want to open the update with ! I didn’t know which program to use. So on Friday 5 Dec. I called support and they installed it for me.
Bo Zerodha isn’t opening though.
Nitinji,
Sorry to say like this. Very dangerous situation your IT team has thrown your customers. Pi is not working. ZT is not working. Web version is not working. Phone is not lifting( alloted only one phone for call and trade ). Why cant arrange 5 to 6 phones temporarily for call and trade and inform the same to customers by message. What your customer has to do if he is getting heavy losses in this situation? Praying god only the best solution. Kindly look into more stebility of Pi and Zt instead of providing new features in Pi. You can provide new features even after one month no body will much bother. But this situation will bother everybody.
Dharma, we have a support team of 50+ on the phone all time, today was just one of those days where we received too many calls. We had sent an update for ZT http://zerodha.com/critical-update/ over the last week, everyone tried to update it only today morning.
Pi, we will have a new release asap, but until then request you to continue using NEST. Make sure to update your NEST as given in the link above. Also when you are running NEST, right click on NEST application and run as administrator.
Dear nitinji,
All the modifications i did what you sugested in critical update day before yesterday and it was closing several times after 85% reached. Again today afternoon i reinstalled with critical updates, but nest charts option is not there in zerodha trader. What we have to do. kindly advise.
Check this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ByAq7C0w5xE, explains what needs to be done. Uninstall NEST completely and follow these steps.
It has been a bad day thus far. No Pi, ZT is cranky, and so is trade.zerodha.com. Unable to use PI (though I did receive a pithy text message that did not offer much by way of explanation). It is worse when there are no updates or reassurances forthcoming from Zerodha. We do understand that there will be some teething troubles when a massive exercise such as this is implemented. If you expect the issues to last a while, please do let us know to help us plan accordingly.
And yes … customer service has been unreachable. Makes one think that calls are being avoided ! This just makes us suspect that there is something seriously wrong. Would appreciate some update / explanation.
By the way, PI is a fantastic software. Having been spoilt by PI, a down-featured NEST charts has made it quite cumbersome to trade on ZT.
Please do give us an update as soon as you can, and apologies for venting on a public forum.
Best
Senthil, yes we are all working on having the latest release of Pi out asap.
When will mobile app start working?
We are working on this, some configuration changes while moving the server.
how to reconcile the charts in terminal PI ???? i didn’t see anything over there which will allow us to do so. there is a gap of a complete one day. . making hard to use technical analysis. please look into it ASAP.
Pravin, some issues because of our upgrade of servers. We will have a new release of Pi asap. To reconcile, you to close the chart and open afresh. If you are talking about any missing data from before, we will have that fixed soon.
this is what i am talking about.
Yes Pravin, our data servers are not in place, these issues will get sorted soon.
placed limit orders but because of your cranky server EVEN AFTER CROSSING THE LIMIT PRICE TRADES ARE NOT EXECUTED ….what am I supposed to do in this case??customer service not picking the phone.
Client ID DA2071
Getting our team check this, there was no issue with our servers today, mainly it was the mobile app.
1) VENKEYS-EQ NEST Order Number 141208000000098 after market order req received Price 463.00 SELL Quantity 9 (Limit reached order not executed)?
2) PRAENG-EQ NEST Order Number 141208000000097 after market order req received Price 09.50 SELL Quantity 500 (Limit reached order not executed)?
why my orders not executed?Why i am supposed to bear the loss?
Ankur, limit orders are sent after market opening, so it is very very tough for your orders to be filled in the first couple of minutes of market opening. It is the same with AMO or placing orders in the first couple of minutes at any brokerage, when prices move around fast without too much volumes.
its not the price at opening of market but 1-2 hours after it….and market stays at this price for minutes altogether with decent volume.
without even looking a the trades you simply said “orders were difficult to push in”
Attaching the image of Venky intraday chart, as you see the price of 463 was right at the opening.
what about PRAENG EQ sir? plz comment!!
ah. didn’t check that, saw only the first stock in your list. Will need to get this checked tomorrow.
Hello Nitin,
New tool is awesome. Please consider below , if possible
Snap Quote Screen:
1. shortcut for SnapQuote not works from other tabs
2. Include Total Traded Value Field
3. Please differentiate LTP value field (give different color)
4. Include Total count of Best Buy Quantity and Best Sell Quantity Like ZT
Chart:
5. Include shotcuts like Ctrl+N and Ctrl+X
6. Include Pivot points
Hi Nitin,
I don’t how you are missing my queries. 🙂
Regards
Saravanan
Mobile app still not working, seems like mobile app is last in ur priority and may be not an important one..should’nt u guys must have tested it before this morning..dont think server capacity implementation was done in responsible and professional way. Having seen on and off issues eith mobile app in last few days and todays disaster, one would think before opening a trade and clearing that trade might be difficult if ur systems works in same manner..zerodha, u have disappointed me.
Yep, like I said no excuses. But what happened today was an accident, we had done everything possible before migrating, but we didn’t anticipate this web and mobile issue.
Nithin, If you had done indeed done everything possible, you should have anticipated these issues. The question is have you learnt any lessons and what confidence can we the customers have that you will do better in future ? Thanks
No excuses, but we will try to make up for this slip up.
Hi sir my name is rahul i opened an account last month and i let you know that i’m very very happy with your service, i’m working with sharekhan for last 8 years and i get sliced with their brokerage.
sir is there any Advance decline ratio or Eq f&o turnover in Pi, If there is not can you add this feature?
and sir congrats in advance for PI software launch.
Not as of now Rahul
Dear Sir, Today morning Mobile App stopped working. As I am working I will trade only using mobile. Then afternoon I got a message from Zerodha that updating process is going on and it will be up soon. Can we able to trade tomorrow. And fortunately today market is down 🙂
Yes Rathish, you should be able to trade tomorrow.
Hi Folks,
I’m one of them to whom ZT worked fine without any issue today. I updated http://zerodha.com/critical-update/ yesterday.
thanks
tarak
why LIEN and SET OFF form on page 17 of KYC, When client will give POA for deemat account ato Zerodha
This was in case of bad debits and where our clients have both equity and commodity accounts.
so, a client that do not wish to open a commodity account with you, i.e. they only wish to have equity trading, they need not fill this lien and set off form, am i right
Yes, you may opt not to sign it. Actually the new forms that will be up on our site soon doesn’t have the lien and set off form.
WHAT IS EXECUTED ORDER?
SAY I TRADE 5 TIMES IN ONE DAY IN CASH AT DIFFERENT POINT OF TIME.,THE CONTRACT NOTE GENERATED WILL BE ONE, BUT WOULD IT BE 5 DIFFERENT EXECUTED ORDER OR ONE EXECUTED ORDER? AND SAY I PURCHASE 5 DIFFERENT SCRIPT AT ONE POINT OF TIME AND SELL 2 SCRIPTS AT THE SAME TIME, WOULD IT BE ONE EXECUTED ORDER OR 7 EXECUTED ORDERS
It would be 5 different orders in your first case. It will be 7 different orders in the second. Check this blogpost.
Now I am trying to open Zerodha mobile, it says ‘ unable to register device, contact admintrator’?
Yes, we are running a few fixes right now.
Nitin and team Zerodha,
I do understand that you are trying something very good. But in the meanwhile we are having some harrowing time. Today I removed and installed both ZT and Pi several times. After installation Pi never asked for password. The charts were faulty as all time-frame charts showed one candle for the whole day (See attached image). I believe Pi had a problem with MCX charts. Further, I was not able to transfer fund to the trading account through pay-in option in Pi.
The ZT was equally bad. Nest Plus was not installing and charts could not be used. In fact new ZT is not showing nest plus tick box at the startup to click.
It was a no trade day again because of technology problems. It has been quite frustrating few days Nitin, must admit. Hope we all will get out of it very soon.
Cannot complain much on Pi because we are backtesting it. But we should not be having problems with ZT.
Thank you.
Yes, it has been extremely frustrating for me as well today. Server upgradation made some changes in configuration, this requires some changes on Pi. We will put up a new release soon. In case of ZT/NEST, can you follow this video, explains how to install everything: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ByAq7C0w5xE
Hi nithin i am very sorry to say u that zerodha service becomes pathetic now a days because again and again i am getting the same problem in zerodha q. when i select p/l summary for the month from jan to til date not displaying instead it shows me brokerage zero total charges zero. I think some serious bug occured. Please try to resolve this issue else need to change my broker. This is not the first time raising this kind of issue on this almost 4 th time. MY ID for u r reference DO0042. Omprakash. Please ask one of u r rep to call me and resolve this issue. My phone number is 9566068331.
¶
hi,
can you please add the market depth ladder with at least 15 bid/ask view.Presently you just provide only best 5 Bid/ask. It would be a great tool for intraday trading and so called ladder trading.
thanks.
I transferred funds to my Zerodha a/c 3 hours back and the money was deducted from my bank a/c but not funded to my Zerodha a/c. I have sent two emails to customer service and nothing has been done. It seems you guys think this is some sort of a video game and not a real system with real money and real people.
It has become completely impossible to call customer service, I tried 16 times (yes, I counted) and every time the line was busy or kept ringing for a while and then disconnected.
How long can people put up with this nonsense I wonder ?
DS2864
Saikat, will get someone to call you back. The last two days has been a nightmare of sorts after the recent update we did. Our lines have been continuously clogged. This should settle down in the next 1/2 days.
Nithin, I wish I could say “thanks”, but…
… the same problem today, still waiting for my funds transferred from HDFC Bank this morning (I only did 30k because I was wary). If we can’t get funds in time, how the hell are we supposed to trade ?
The worst part is that your customer service team is trying to blame HDFC bank for the delay, while the bank has clearly transferred the money instantaneously. So, its either a payment gateway problem or a problem with your site, and on both counts it is Zerodha’s responsibility to fix this once and for all. I know other users are facing the same, since I have been in touch with some.
We are not talking about any fancy functionality here, just bread and butter stuff. No mitigating circumstances for failing to deliver on these.
Again, your customers are your best source of marketing, and you are losing goodwill fast.
I am having Reliance Securities and Zerodha online account.Both uses Omnesys software.Till last week I did have any problem.After the recent updation,Zerodha does not work.Your technical people are not able to solve this.Should I have two differnt computers ( one for each )
Getting someone to call you back on this.
when will make Pi to all zerodha client
hi
charts r not updating from 2 days.
yes, we did an upgrade of our server which has changed a bunch of things. This will be fixed soon.
Hi Nitin,
We continue to suffer the agonies friend. While Pi has been awful in last few days, ZT charts are in no way better. The candles are showing wrong High and Low. Have a look at the screenshot. You support services is woefully lacking. I am trying since morning but have not been able reach your executive. Sent a mail as was advised in an sms… no response. Very sad state. Hope things will improve pretty quickly. Otherwise, Zerodha may loose trust quite rapidly.
Sorry to be harsh because Zerodha had set very high high standard in technology as well as support. But the last few days have been quite stressful and agonising.
Thank you
Bimal, the charts on ZT/NEST is not in our control as it is maintained by our tech vendor Omnesys. Pi, a bunch of things changed during the server migration. We will need a few more days before it is up completely.
VIJU PAUL
I am having Reliance Securities and Zerodha online account.Both uses Omnesys software.Till last week I did have any problem.After the recent updation,Zerodha does not work.Your technical people are not able to solve this.Should I have two differnt computers ( one for each )
Check this post Viju, if you are having trouble doing it yourself, can get someone to help you do this.
speed has increased signficantly since yesterday , but charts are not updating , in intraday prospective . charts are starting from point when we login the system
Yes Vinesh, the migration did a few changes on our data server. Everything should be back to normal soon.
Hi,
I m sure PI is going to revolutionise the way trading is done especially by retailers like us.
Would appreciate if you could incorporate the following suggestions in the final release of PI
1. Short cut tool bars for drawing horizontal lines, trendlines on the either side of the chart
2. Please allow to change the time frame in the existing chart itself. Also, please allow the horizontal lines and trendlines drawn in higher time frame are getting reflected in the lower time frames as well. This would help immensely.
3. Please bring BO soon.
I am sure PI will rock.
1. Yes, in the next release.
2. This will be tough.
3. Yes.
Hi nithin is there any new application going to launch for mobile trading. I heard that kite apps going to launch. if yes can u please tell me its future and whn it is going to launch
Yes, http://kite.trade/ , web version which will also be mobile compatible by end of this month. The mobile app might take a little longer.
I am doing only pair (ARBITRAGE) trading and some time good trades with volumes. is that Pi supports to get charts for pair trading. i mean now i am using the same in amibroker. is there any chance to get work in PI for ARBITRAGE Trading.
You mean plot two scrips on the same chart? This is not possible currently.
Hi Nitin,
My mobile recently upgrade to android 5 as I am using nxsus 5. Is mobile app is working for this ?
The lollipop update should be available in the next 3 days.
Hello Nithin,
as you described in this blog, by Pi- Ami bridge ,trading coulde be fully automated,
1.can we also modify/cancel our orders through AFL code ?
2.can we get order id through any parameter ?
thanks.
Ajay, not in the first release of Pi bridge. But yeah, very soon the bridge will do two way communication. The only issue with Ami would be in feeding the details back to it, don’t know if there are API’s for that on AMI. Let us know if you think there is a way, we can call you on this.
Hello Nithin,
Right Now ,i am getting API with presto of Symphony,
and my front end is .Net . these API are provided by Broker or service provider , so i am unable to get your point about API.
you may contact on my phone 9425126916 or on my mail .
my client id is DA1727
thanks
Ajay, your custom front end using .NET API can communicate both ways with the OMS/RMS. Amibroker on the other hand, can’t really receive these details, if there is a way you are using the .NET API to receive order details into Amibroker, would love to speak to you.
Cheers,
Nithin,
Thanks For Prompt Response. i have NCFM derivative Certification. how can i get API
to two way communication with your system.
thanks.
Ajay, we are still not live on Pi bridge. Once done, we will give you that access.
What’s going on here…i m planning to open an a/c here but there has lots of problem…
We had a major server upgrade over the weekend. We had requested many to update and check if the new version of NEST works fine on the mock markets last saturday. I guess we should have followed up more. Everyone tried to update at same time on Monday, and yeah we have had issues with everyone calling us to help them update. Web and mobile had some configuration issues, but most of it has been sorted.
Dear Tradinglearner82,
I am using zerodha for last two years..never had any problems except last 2 days due to update related issues. Looks like things are stable now and its working smoothly yet again.
we like pi.waiting for final release when will it happen please notice us
Certain things slowing us down, we are looking for the final release by end of this month.
Sir, Will there be any charges to use Pibridge….also please send the pibridge dll file to check mock trades and report bugs if any…thanks
Yes, there will be a small charge to use the bridge. We haven’t finalized it yet, but we will have more details on it soon.
Where to download PI for testing purpose?
You have to send us a request first to enable. The link to put the request is mentioned on the top of this blogpost.
Please resolve the Pi server issue soon, because the ZT charts had gone unreliable and of limited use. The problem with charts after critical update is:
1) Charts are flickering frequently, and the interface has gone grisly.(Not even able to save my preferred Interface)
2) Zoom is reduced to very dense candle limits in one minute chart. Not able to see the indicators plotted properly.
3) NOT ABLE TO LAY TWO INDICATORS OF SAME TYPE with different time frame. So the crossover (with same types) are not possible at all.
4) Intraday charts are already scrapped. Did hoped to have it back with this update but disappointed.
ZT is already going down in terms of productive technical analysis. So there are lots of hopes riding on Zerodha Pi. The very glimpse I had of Pi look really promising with smart interface and breakthrough technical analysis. Will like to see Pi back on track soon. Please resolve the issues with server thoroughly and let us get going for TRADE WITH ZERODHA.
Wishing you LUCK!!!
Yes Shahnawaz, we will have a new release asap.
Hi team zerodha,
Does mobile app work on latest android version ‘lollypop’.. Will upgrade my mobile software only after your confirmation.
Not yet Rahul, there were too many things happening last few days. We are testing it out today/tomm, we should have it up early next week.
this is the error mgs i am getting , what to do ?
Satya, have you installed the latest release of Pi from Q? My guess is that you are still using the old installation.
u r right . now it’s ok ..
hi,
the zerodha terinal has become unstable after i installed the latest version. The help desk operator told me that it requires minimum 1 Mbps speed. but before the critical update it was working fine. now its keeps disconnecting all the time. my internet speed is around 2 Mbps. also to bring to ur notice my trade tiger works just fine even now. although i dnt place orders there.
please help me on this as i am a futures trader and price freezing is like doomsday for me.
thx
puneet
Will get someone to look at this asap.
Puneet, can you send an email to [email protected]. This might be happening because you are running trade tiger and sharekhan on the same platform.
Hello I have installed latest version zeroodhda but i couldn’t able to log in,am using windows 7 enterprises.
Best to send an email to [email protected] with your client ID and contact number.
Hi,
ZT has a workaround that allows one to run 2 or 3 instances concurrently. Can the same be done with Pi ?
Thanks
Really? How can one do that?
I found it here : http://support.zerodha.com/kb/faq.php?id=91
Thanks.. I thought it’s possible to log in with the same ID in multiple instances simultaneously.
Yes, and it is a lot more easier.
I am using latest version of ZT but MCX charts are not neat, I checked Data Table but the high and low of entire session is the same.
Bomdila, wait for a few days, Pi is almost ready for MCX as well.
Nitin sir, there are lots of trader who like ZT/Nest Trader only, in them I’m also one. Pi is a good alternative but please don’t put ZT aside. For me Nest Trader is good now, so please cure MCX charts / Table/vwap data in ZT server.
Bomdila most of our clients are on NEST/ZT and our focus is on that. There is a separate team handling Pi. The issue with NEST is that Omnesys/Reuters is the technology vendor for the platform, and we can’t really control what they do with it. They decided to stop Plus charting and hence all the issues
dear nithin ji ,
i have notice one thing about zerodha Pi and want to share with you . the CONTRAST between background colour (black) and font colour (white) in zerodha theme is some what less , when compared to zerodha trader , nse now , odin , i.e what i mean to say that ,black is not completly black, and white is not completly white and some what dull colour is present there . this issue must be resolved as soon as possible , because the less contrast will put more strain on the eyes .
Totally Second that.
A Complete black(background) and white(text) theme like the one in Nest should be provided
Will have this checked.
Need Pi chart to be completely functional soon as the latest Nest critical update has caused a catastrophe to nest charting
Yep, working on it.
pi is not working till last week please tell me how fix it
i entered my user id and password then click on login nothing happen
my client id rj0733
Japjit, a bunch of things changed when we did the update. If you are not able to login after downloading the latest version of Pi, we will have a new release of Pi by next week.
Hallo Nithin
Pleas Set Symbol & Period Time Changing option For Chart Window And Most Gainer Looser & Most Volume Value Window For New PI That’s Best option For Active Traders Thank You
Changing time period from the chart requires structural change. This might take a while. Gainers/Loosers, yeah, we will start giving such data soon.
INFY: why are the calls and puts not reflecting the accurate strike prices based on the underlying in Pi?
Karthik, my guess is that you are using Quick login, and hence the new contract list has not been updated. Can you login once without the quick login option ticked.
what’s wrong with all your systems? can’t close any of my positions
Between 9.18 to 9.30, one of our lines connecting to the NSE was down. So clients on this line, the orders were not going through. We have backup lines, but it took around 10 to 15 mins to switch.
I have seen a terminal in India (don’t remember the broker name) they give you options to choose between their data servers while logging into the terminal. they have 3 or 5 servers don’t remember the exact number. so if one server is down clients can logout this and login to to another. i think zerodha also should have this kind of setup bcoz this is not the first time we are facing server issue.
Siva, we have something that auto switches from one to another in case a server is down. We have all that in place, the recent issue was because of the upgrade.
tradetiger.exe – of sharekhan has 20 active servers and one can swicth over manually or autoselection
Hi
What is happening to Zerodha Trader? Feed is not coming. Is anyone there> This has been a very bad week so far…Never expected from Zerodha.
Between 9.18 to 9.30, one of our lines connecting to the NSE was down. So clients on this line, the orders were not going through. We have backup lines, but it took around 10 to 15 mins to switch. It has been one of the weeks for us.
Mere apology will not help..! Please ensure this does not happen again…!!!
Can you please let me know by when we can expect range bars to be added to Pi?
Nachiket, we first want the final release to be out, we will work on indicators/chart types after that.
Dear Nitin,
The PI worked well for most of 10th Dec and the first few hours of 11th Dec. But it is back to its worst of past few days. Today’s candles are not updating (only one candle is representing the time period from opening till the chart is opened). The candle is also giving wrong information. For example, the high shown is the candle is not correct.
Thanks
Ye Bimal, like I said earlier, the server upgrade from the weekend, a few things have changed. We are looking at having everything fixed in the next couple of days.
dear nithin ji
we are totally now on Pi for charts ,after omnesys downgrade its charts, but the charts produced by Pi are not trust worthy till now , they stoped working some time . yesterday was the day every thing was right , but today , charts are showing data starting from 2:30pm in commodity and from 10:30am for nifty.
please make it more reliable and accurate so that we can TRADE instead of writing comments here .
thanks
Like I have mentioned earlier, a bunch of things changed during our server upgrade last weekend. Give it a couple of days more and Pi will start working normally.
missing of some data from the chart produces false signal by modifying indicators and it is very FATEL for day traders , who uses charts for their entry and exits . please leave eyery thing aside and concentrate on the charts so that they can work correctly , . after all you had advertise Pi as a trading terminal with advance charting solution .
thanks
Yes Vinesh, like I have said a few times, things changed during our recent upgrade. Pi is still in the beta, our final release after the recent issue has been pushed to first week of JAN.
Dear Nitin ji,
Hope we will get lollypop andorid 5 app (zerodha mobile trading app) till this weekend… Is any updation on this?
Brijendra singh
DB0630
A few of our clients are trying this out today/tomm, if everything is good we should have it out by Monday/Tuesday.
HI
different time frame shows different prices
thank you.
Having this checked.
Hi Nithin,
I have a quick question on Pi. Some execution algorithms for high volume traders were packaged as Zerodha i3 for dealer terminals. Would such algorithms be available for Pi as well. (I do understand that retail traders are not permitted to use these algorithms).
Thanks
We have plans on that, but too early to discuss about it. Our first task on hand is to launch Pi.
Pi is messed up again, just now. can’t seem to update open orders, not showing filled orders on the admin position.
Karthik, the admin position behavior has changed after the upgrade. You have to say get positions, to see the udpated positions in the admin position window. We are fixing all of this.
Hi,
When I tried to add 200 SMA, I got the following error msg today.
Checking this
hi,
do you have pi 64 bit version available?
No, presently only 32 bit.
nithin ji
when i login at morning charts are ( in commodity) working well and candles are forming well, i loged out at 12:30 and login again at 3:00 pm , now the chart is showing single candle of 10:00 am to 2:30pm , and there after , this was the problem which i also faced yesterday , and also talked about here.
kindely look at the problem ,because this is creating problem in chart indicators,
Vinesh, we are fixing the server issues on Pi that changed after the recent upgrade. This is just a test/beta, all these issues will be fixed before the final release.
do you get Pibridge to amibroker approval from nse ? is it available now to put order to exchange for real trade?
For semi-automated there is no approval as such required. We are doing some final fixes, it should be available soon.
dear sir,
I have already summited the survey form for testing pi last week with my I’d RC0258 but till now I don’t get any response from your side.I think this time
you will help me.
Our next release will happen in 3 to 4 days, we will have Pi enabled for all pending requests by then. Also the current version has some issues because of the server update we did last week.
Hi – See error attached on the Indusindbk trade..bought once but calculating PnL different from executed prices..it’s wierd. Tradebook is different from Admin position. This error both in Pi and Zt.
Karthik, the server upgrade has changed a bunch of things at the back end. We will have all things fixed and give a new release on 1st Jan 2015. Until then, I’d suggest it is best to use NEST to place trades.
nithin ji
UNABLE TO CONNECT TO THE DATA SERVER. SHOULD BE SOON . this message is flashed every time i try to open any chart since morning, kindely confirm me whether server is realy down ,or it is my system fault.
Vinesh, we are working on the backend. We will take atleast 10 more days to have it all fixed and also to work on the multiple requests that we have received from clients. So we are aiming for Jan 1st 2015 for the official release of Pi.
please sent me zerodha pi sofware. id no. da1014
A L, we are currently working on a bunch of requests/bugs/upgrades as requested by our clients. We will give Pi out to everyone from Jan 1st 2015.
Today is Jun-2017 and still there are many bugs exists in your applications.
i am a trader in zerodha, plz give me the exact date of launch of
Pi.
We are aiming for Jan 1st 2015 release.
Nitin,
I am extreemly sorry to state that so far the PI is not working at all. More ove the nest trader as well stopped working today . I reported this and they told me there is some problem. I could not square off the positions and cancel my pending order and I made a loss toady because of this error. Kindly get this rectified and get us the pi version as soon as possible.
Regards
M.Anantha Raman
Anantha, a bunch of things changed when we did the server upgrade. We are working on it, and have decided to give out the final beta release with all the fixes in bugs that people have spotted till now on Jan 1st 2015. We don’t want to put another release before that as it would slow us down.
While you are it, kindly also get multiple marketwatch feature on the final version. Thanks in advance.
Nithin,
Greetings!!, We are still facing issue with dealer terminal. Is there any time frame you can solve. Today it went down in between market hrs. Its very dangerous for autotrading. Can you please let me know any time frame infra will be alright. thanks a lot
Hi! Can we expect to have Pi for Mac? Also would like to know the timeframe! Otherwise having a great deal of inconvenience, and almost having barriers to trade! Please, get Pi listed on the Apple app store.
Adam, Pi uses dotnet, so it won’t work on Mac. We will be launching Pi officially 1st week of Jan 2015. We are working on our webapplication Kite, which will work on Mac, but it will take atleast 6 to 8 weeks more.
I know that very well! What I’m asking is desktop version for Mac? Do you have any plans? Then only I’ll open my account!
No plan atleast for now.
Pi not working and you have a plan to implement by 1st Jan 2015. At least you should have left the Nest as it is, to enable us to trade using the usual advanced charts. This should have been your mitigation plan. Which is not. We could not trade without charts for the next 15 days. If the PI could not give the advanced charts from 1st jan, then again we could not trade. What is the workaround you have? I need advanced charts to trade.
Sundar, NEST is a vendor product (omnesys/reuters), and they stopped supporting the Plus charts. Unfortunately nothing much we can do about it. You will have to use the NEST charts until then.
see attached ZT error message. Tried bunch of times with new installation. Still giving me this error message. Please help
¶
Karthik, I guess someone already called you on this, and everything seems to be okay.
Hi,
Since i was having issues with the nest trader charts, your person suggested i try the new pi instead, as suggested i sent a mail to your office, was asked to fill an online form which i did, but i am yet to get the link to download and use the software, i have sent reminder mails but still i havent got a response.
can you help me out here.
thanks
Hari, we have stopped giving out releases on Pi,and currently working on fixing all the issues and bugs that were spotted. We will release it for all, Jan 1st week.
guess then your people /website shouldnt advise us to fill in forms to get the demo.
Will update the blogpost thanks.
Nitin, I am a Zerodha trader
Some where in the comments I saw that you don’t have Pi for 64 bit right now
Do you have 64 bit Pi in the final release ?
No Praveen. It makes no difference actually.
Pi software’s first official launch will have Algo Trading (Fully & Semi automatic) & Pi Bridge to link AMIBROKER & Meta Trader?
Bharath, it will have semi-automated option. We are hoping to have the bridge ready as well, but not sure about the bridge.
Nithin,
I had some problems with Pi today. I put cover buy order and it didnt show up in the orders window. I closed and opened ZT and the order is executed after I login in ZT. When I checked later, I had similar problem with buy order but not sell order. Apparently there is some blocking delay somewhere for buy order.
Pi charts had a problem today. Till 10:10 or so there is only one candle. i.e. After yesterdays 3:30 candle, I see one candle for 10:10 which covers 9:15 to 10:10 price move.
My moving average setup went useless because of this.
There are many minor issues with Pi. I do not think Jan 1st week for public release is a good plan.
This app still needs lots of fixing even for existing features.
btw, If you people at zerodha is happy with Pi, please share which vc++ runtime and dot net versions are installed in your machines (along with os version).
Thanks
Kars
kars, we are all working on getting pi out by 1st week of Jan, so yes the current version has a bunch of bugs, from data server not being live to not being able to login. We will have all of this sorted and release Pi officially by 1st week of Jan.
RR2650
SIR
I Made a request to enable the pi on 6/12/2014, i filled the survey form also. still i didn’t find any link in my BO.
Ravi, we have stopped on giving out the beta, and we are working on having a release to all our clients by 1st week of Jan.
dera nithin ji and tshiva
while you r preparing to launch of final beta version of Pi , there are some mandatory requirement which should be included . as you know you have so many clients(35k-45k) and every other client have their own preferances in respect of visual and function of the trading software and you can not throw out the preferances of your software developer( tradelab ) on the clients,i am telling this because they (tradelab) provide very – very -very much less options to setting individual preferances in visual and functioning dept .
starting with visuals=
1) they provide only four themes for application style an no other option to change it , as a default, black background and white font with maximum contrast is only needed, but the ZERODHA THEAM has less contrast and background is not completly black and fonts are off white whict put extra strain on eyes ,kindely consider this issue as top priority.
2) no option for hiding grid lines is present there
3) snap quote window and oder entry window always open in the middel of screen , there should be an option to save last used layout ( as present in odin)
4)column width has to be adjusted every time of login . it should be saved as last used automaticly.
function=
1) cross hair is basic need of any chart, which is not present here .please ask them (tradelab ) why?
2)no option to remove volume from chart.
3)why zoom in -zoom out is not enabled with mouse and key board, as i suggested earlier?
4) every time when we open chart they open as candles chart amd templates are applied then to it. why there is no option to “save as default template” present there .
please consider these issues before final release of Pi .
( those fellow traders are in support of my arguments please put your views below this)
thanks
Vinesh, yep some of the changes you have asked for will be there by Jan 1st week. But some of what you are asking is something that will take us longer.
nithin ji
thanks for your prompt reply , waiting for january . but some problems are there with zerodha trader it hangs very often during the whole session .while there is no such problem with other brokers using nest ( i am talking of edelweiss xtream trader).
Vinesh, the charting on NEST is what is causing freezing issues. Can you try without the charts and see if you face this.
nithin ji
one more suggestion , if it can be implemented-technically, that if it is possible to login zerodha trader and Pi at the same time . then please consider it from january.
Not at the same time Vinesh, you will have to logout of one and login to another.
hi,
please give me a brief description of Pi, and particularly scanner
We will put out a complete section on all aspects of trading on Pi by the 1st week of Jan.
hey nithin you tell me last week you resolve my pi not working problem but till now no solution
i getting problem in trading because of nest only 1 chart at 1 time
i open zerodha account because of pi
please solve my problem as early as possible
my client id rj0733
Japjit, like we have recently communicated, we are currently fixing all the issues that the people testing Pi have give us as feedback. We will be good to launch this for everyone by 1st week of Jan. Until then, request you to trade on ZT/NEST
Nithin,
While starting the Pi, it has load, Marketwatch, NewsReader, Order and all the charts I may have opened during the previous session.
This will obviously take a lot of time and uneccessary Internet time.
You can load these as per the settings provided in “usersettings”
Marketwatch is a must
order tab may be opened only if there are orders pending or trades that are not squareoff.
NewsReader can be purely on usersetting, which should reduce some resources
I may have opened many charts just for checking that may or may not be important. I feel it is better to provide a check box on the usersetting panel for loading the charts or not.
You may also think of adding a checkbox on the “alert” setting for each scrip to open its chart on startup.
On an advanced setup, you may think of adding a facility for “remembering” the settings for each of the charts like various lines, levels, type of chart etc.
just a few ideas.
{by the way, I think you should take some time for launching the next version of Pi, than the 1st week of Jan. The holidays can be a problem and I am sure you don not want yet another botchedup job. It is better to postpone it to the 2nd or 3rd week , make sure every thing alright}.
hi
please include SL order&BO in Pi chart, curently SL-M only
Placing limit orders on the chart is an issue because, if the order is partially filled it might create a confusion for the trader. BO on Pi chart directly will take some time.
Nitin,
I had put the Index in my watchlist CNX Nifty and BankNinfty basically to view the charts , while exiting I have saved the settings, when restarted again both the index scrips disappear. Please look into this.
Nitin Sir,
From past two days, was not able to see the charts on Zerodha Pi. Trying to load the charts gives a message “Unable to connect to data server. Should be soon.”
Not able to trade since.
Like I have mentioned on the top of the blog, we are in the process of fixing bugs/issues and be ready to release Pi for everyone 1st week of Jan. If you send an email to [email protected], he will be able to give you a temporary fix to this problem.
Hi Nithin,
In the ‘Pi’ final version, is it possible to place “stoploss & target price” in one window/single order for existing position – so that as soon as either of stoploss or target price trade takes place the other will automatically get cancelled immediately.
This will be of great help and avoid loss to the trader if he places seperate stoploss & target limit price order and goes away from terminal – And both are hit in volatile day in short time.
Best regards
Vasant Naik
Vasant, have you seen the bracket order feature, that is already available on NEST, and will be also soon available on Pi.
Hi Nithin, thanks for your prompt response. I have seen the “bracket order” feature – but this “BO” feature is intra-day product and can be used while placing a new order.
My request is extend the same feature for carried forward/existing future position square-off with “trailng stoploss / target price” option. Since the position is existing/carried forward, full margin is already accounted for existing position.
The problem I am facing for carried forward future positon is that I have to place 2 orders – one for SL and another one for limit/target price – and I have to be alert & manually cancel the other order when one of them gets executed.
May be I am missing out on some Nest trader facility. I can explain it further on phone – please advise contact person/number.
Best Regards
Vasant Naik
Ah got it, BO for overnight positions is something that is not possible right now.
Dear Nitin,
Pls let me know by when exactly your Kite Web Application is likely to launch and available for users like us…
when can we expect the modified Mobile App similar that of PI or KITE.
Regards
Venkat
This will take atleast 5 to 6 weeks more.
Hi Nithin,
Is it possible to add below feature in MT4 to Pi plugin,
Buy or sell on a single button click on mt4 (using MT4 one click trading) and the trade gets automatically executed in zerodha Pi.
Trader should be able to save the default order type, quantity, product code (NRML/ MIS) etc. on Zerodha Pi so that when Buy / sell command comes from Mt4 it automatically gets executed in Zerodha Pi.
I really appreciate Zerodha for talking customers feedback while develpoing trading platflorm. Would like to know if this feature will be supported.
Thanks
Satish, it is a little tricky with MT4, as MT4 doesn’t really let you fire orders to anything other than the MT4 servers. Also the regulations won’t let us allow you to fire an order automatically from a front end which is not approved by the exchange. But I get what you are saying, and we are working on something that can work similar to what you have asked.
Hi Zerodha,
Do we have option to put GTC orders in the PI software ??
No prince, not as of now.
charts not coming up since morning. The error reads ” cant connect to the data server “
i have mentioned before, expert advisor and scripted alerts flash for a second or two and disappear. They dont even give us time to think. Its not possible to navigate through the alerts. In back test price is not seen. Are these things being fixed in the final release or not
Yes they are getting fixed. btw, what do you mean by “in back test price not seen”?
Hi Nithin, Logging in late in the discussion , huge efforts,.. congrats..
what I cud see is most of the focus is on charting software and algo system.Are we getting few luxuries in order management as well.My wish list is
1.If I can include multiple targets in the bracket orders for one order.
2.If these targets can be carried forward to position trades , rite now bracket orders are available only in intraday
3. If I can take a trade in futures on the basis of spot without me manually calculating It and system doing it instead.
4. If I can get bracket orders in MCX as well.
Thanks!
Dear Nithin sir
As our pi is going to be the best trading software of india I would like to request u to add some features for it which I didn’t find in beta testing.
1.As u know pro money flows in to or out of d stock once they have gone over the privous days high or under d privious days low hence Pi should scan through your basket of core trading stocks and look for a stock that is about to move above its privious day’s high or low.
2.Market watch should be group wise with respect to exchange defined. screen shot of ventura attached herewith
3.Mrkt summery should displayed so that retail trader would identify where the action is.
Best 20 wrost 20 top traded screen shot of ventura attached herewith
Hello Nitin,
Hope we are in line with Pi release date. Since last week the Pi test version that I was using is not working properly so I am back to ZT again. But in chart the candles are showing only Open and Close. It is not showing high and low. Is it a problem with my settings or is it a problem with ZT?
By the way I must inform you that I tried to get help of your support team but my phone went unanswered. Again lost quite a few rupees on unattended call Nitin (Hope I qualify as an ‘active trader’). Feel that your support team/infrastructure needs a lot of bolstering. I never face such problem with Ventura. Reaching them is only a click away. Anyway, living the day with hope that Zerodha will give us great experience.
Thanks
Hi Sir,
If i Place an order in Market type order in AMO for which price it will take open price or some other price.
and please confirm is there any charges applying for AMO.
No charges for AMO. IF you place a market order as AMO, the order gets placed at market price once market opens, and if you choose limit order in AMO, it gets placed at the price you have chosen.
nithin ji
i want to know that, Pi release in january first week would be beta release for all or it would be final beta release, or release candidate. kindely explain
nithin ji
when you are preparing for next Pi release, there are few suggestion for future,regarding the visual and functationality of Pi.
Pi can’t be used in multi system , because neither of its window is detached from main window , please considerd it .
omnesys nest trader can be consider as benchmark in this regard because many discount brokers using nest,also nse now is one of that , any trading software developed must be one stage above in all respect and not 2-3 steps leg behind . because as a day trader we need SPEED- ACCURECY- BEST VISUAL -SEEMLESS FUNCTATIONALITY.
Vinesh, it will be a final beta release, every window on Pi can be popped out and placed on a different monitor.
Hi Nithin,
I don’t know. in my system The pi software is not working. charts are not getting also when i add new chart .it completely not working. can you plz help me what to do.? i know this is a beat version but at present my Zerodha trader also not working last 2 weeks i am not doing any trade. can you plz help me what to do now.?
Best Regards
Sharan
Pi will start working soon (1st week of Jan is when we will have our new release). ZT has been working fine, you just need to apply the latest update. Check this. If you are not able to update, send an email to [email protected], we will call back and help you out.
hi nithinn
please add multiple Marketwatch option in Pi
please add multiple Market watch.So that we can easily track and also please let me know when Can we can expect range bars to be added to Pi.Eagerly waiting for it
Hi Nithin,
Sorry to say that my trading experience has not been comfortable since the new NEST update till today too.
Small but important things are missing like Alerts, SPAN Calculator etc are missing, I have raised a ticket mentioning these concerns however they are not yet resolved.
Because of this I am desperately waiting for trial activation on Pi, I had requested this approximately 4 weeks back however my trial for Pi has not yet been activated.
Could you please advise when the Pi would be active. Also when will NEST become like what it was before?
Thanks
Sukesh
Pi is being released in batches, so you should get it early next year if you’ve already requested.
Zerodha Trader is being tested for stability without the alerts and SPAN calculator features as they were causing some issues.
Alerts should be back sometime next month. And we have our online margin calculator at http://www.zerodha.com/margin-calculator
Hi Hanan,
Thanks for the update. Issue with Online SPAN calculator is that the prices are not refreshed till the markets are opened the next day.
For example if I calculate margins after closing of markets @ 3:30 PM today, it’ll calculate the margin requirement based on closing price yesterday.
Is there a way to fix this?
Thanks
Sukesh
We get the updated SPAN report only the next morning so it wouldn’t be possible to update these values after the close of the day’s session. The only work around is to get ballpark figures by using the previous day’s values until the opening of the market.
How come Zerodha does not offer demo account for practicing a particular strategy?
I wish one can simple create a demo account and start practicing……
For example: I would like to create a demo account for 200000 and practice my strategy………
I called Zerodha and they dont have any practice account…..
Subhash, actually no brokerage in India offers you a simulated trading environment. But we are trying to build something out, might take a bit.
Actually ICICIDirect does.And though the platform is not excellent (sluggish,sometimes and no charting) they actually done pretty decent job.
I use it heavily to learn future and options trading,and from that onward I also joined their Center for Learning and actually forked out money for three courses.
Hi Nithin,
I have to restart my trading do you suggest me to wait for PI next year or start trading in ZT by transferring my amount in the current system.
i wanted to know the transition from ZT to PI of cash in my account.
regards
Arun
Arun, ZT and Pi will work in parallel, so there is no transition as such. You can logout of ZT and login to Pi and trade using the same funds. So if you want to transfer funds and start, you can do this right away.
Hi Sir,
I have free cash in my account but couldn’t able to sell any share. the error showing check holding for entity acount-DS4593 across exchange across segment across product
hi santosh
i am answering your query as every one in zerodha is busy for pi launch or go live with pi. (isn’t it nithin sir)
so
if you don’t have shares in dmat you would not be able to sell in normal order.
if you want to short sell for intraday plz check order it should be mis type
Hey,
Getting an error while opening charts in Pi “Unable to connect to data server. Should be soon.” Neither stock or index charts are opening. What might be the reason?? Also, wanted to ask whether ZT will be discontinued after implementation of Pi?
Rgds,
Ankit.
The new release of Pi will be up by next weekend. ZT will continue to run in parallel with Pi.
Hey,
So chart not working is problem faced by everyone right?? Its not my computer specific..
Yes, we are currently working on the new release of Pi, the previous one has problem with charts. We will give you all the new release by next weekend.
Please tell me
When will PI comming date of jan 2015
We should have it out in the next 10 days.
hey Nitin Sir i have already submited PI sw application form but i am not getting any reply …
Rachit, we were working on all the issues that were spotted, so we will have the final release by next weekend. You will be enabled by then.
okay thank you sir ..You and your team doing a very great Job .
hi,
i am using gann levels for intraday trades. Now I am using Trade tiger as charting tool and i have to draw these gann levels horizontally. So please can you incorporate these gann levels (if selected by user as per his/her choice)for all scripts like Equities, Stock & Index Futures, Options, Indexes like Nifty, Banknifty, Currencies etc. These feature will be must for day traders and will be very good feature for Pi and you.
thanking you in anticipation.
Dear Nithin Sir,
Recently opened an Account with Zerodha(29th dec.,11:17 pm) but now i want to know who will guide me to install a zerodha trader software,yesterday opened an account.but feeling like nobody will listen to me.As nobody called me today that “your account has been opened” till noon i dont get any call,so i think i should have to call,not fully satisfied with the customer support.Frankly saying i came to Zerodha just because of low brokerage otherwise i am doing trading with ICICIDIRECT SECURITES.BUT there service is very fast when i open an account,they called me “that my account has been opened”.its okay that you have sent a SMS that my account has been opened.I am not criticising,but just simply saying that yesterday my account has opened but i am not feeling happy.my account has opened not deposited the investment yet.i have opened account(trading,demat&commodity).Also by reading views of some clients that i have to fill the Zerodha Pi software form? Now,i wanna know that if i have to gather all the information whats happening in Zerodha? I FEEL THAT YOUR EXECUTIVE SHOULD CALL ITSELF ABOUT OPENED ACCOUNT,ASKED ABOUT ANY QUERIES,TELL THAT HOW TO INSTALL THE SOFTWARE,SO THAT CLIENT SHOULD FEEL SATISFIED. “DA2880”
My problems regarding zerodha trader has been solved.thanks for support.
1st day of 2015, traders of zerodha will not get their commitment of PI on this happy day.
We are trying our best to have it out before the 1st week of Jan, that is by next weekend.
zerodha trader is not working
Yeah, problems are becoming a bit regular.I am infrequent trader cause I don’t get holidays much but the days I am home,well ZT throws up errors.Z5 keeps me logging out.Fun day.
Release date of PI is Jan 14 2015
But as per Nitin Ji comment it was first week of Jan 2015.
i think zerodha lies every time when you ask about launch date of pi
before jan 1st week they tell last week of dec now 14 jan wait and wait
commitment is more important than your tool pi.we are here at zerodha because of we kept confidence on yours team.please don’t make any mistake to stay here longer.
Hey Nithin Can you tell us when exactly PI would be out ?
Hey Nitin i want to know is there any application or form one has to fill to get PI or it will be available to all after it released. Please tell me
We are working on the final beta release of PI, so for now that link to get Pi is disabled. We will have it out hopefully by next weekend.
If release of Pi is delayed further,it means that there are few more bugs to be removed.Please don’t blame zerodha team for this because they have initiated a revolution in trading history of india with Q ,Quant ,varsity ,pi and kite etc.They don’t gain anything by delaying release of Pi
Please be patient.
i agree with gilari message…. they are working hard…putting their team effort to make Pi better.
release date of next Pi version is fixed ie Pi is not going to release befor 9JAN15 2133 hrs ,( strictly my view) so be patience and keep trading with ZT .
Dear Sir,
Are you going to incorporate Gann Levels on the chart in Pi?
Sir,
Are you going to incorporate Gann Levels on the chart in Pi?
regards
VIJU PAUL
Not in our first release, but we will add them in due course.
1. I have been waiting for the final release in january. When you backtest a strategy in expert advisor, the backtest report includes the time wen the alert was fired and sell/buy. It doesnt include the rate at which alert was fired. Is this being fixed.
2. I have been repeatedly reminding you that the expert advisor flashes for a moment and disappears. there is no provsion to navigate through the alerts. are these being fixed.
3. Are you also releasing amibroker to pi plugin with this release. Does this plugin require subscription to global data feeds or does it extract real time data from pi.
4. For both nest trader and pi, can we use real time data from a vendor other than global data feeds for using amibroker -pi/nest plus plugin.
thanking you
dr.kalyan
1. hmm.. it includes prices at which alert was triggered isn’t it? Can you check this video (go to 12 mins)
2. Yes, this is fixed.
3. Yes we will have the plugin available, you will not be able to extract real time data from Pi (this is not being compliant to exchange data vending rules). You will be able to fire orders directly from Ami.
4. For Amibroker-Pi plugin. Yes, you will be able to use any data vendor on Ami like I mentioned above. For NEST, you will still need GFDL.
Thank You Nithin for the quick reply.
1. i have checked the video and prices are being included in backtest report.
2. In amibroker afl it is possible to control trade price. Like it is possible to fire buy at low and sell at high. In nest plus it was not possible. ( In amibroker afl ” Buyprice= low; sellprice= high; shortprice=high; coverprice=low; is possible). Is similar kind of coding possible in tradescript.
3. In amibroker its possible to control timing of orders like: buy=timenum()>110000; It places buy order after 11 am. Is similar kind of coding possible with tradescript.
2. Yes
3. No
Dear Nithin,
zerodha trader is not working . Kindly help me.
regards
Viju Paul
Best if you can send an email to [email protected] with your client ID
Download link of ZT is not working.
This is an alternative link for you if the original doesn’t work for some reason.
Thanks a lot
Hello,
I am eagerly waiting for the Pi software. My Nest Plus account is not working I am unable to use charts etc.
Please offer me atleast beta version.
Regards,
Amrik
We will have the final beta release of Pi out by this weekend.
There was option to set price alerts (Scrip/Index alert) in ZT which is disabled from past 1 month. Is there similar option/function available in Pi?
It is very difficult keep on watching the price levels each time and that too for multiple scrips. Please enable this in ZT asap.
???
Scrip alert will be available again on ZT soon. Pi has alerts.
Great Job and excellent software. Would please include Donchian channel or Highest high lowest low indicator thanks
dear Nitin sir,
i have deleted the older version of zerodha trader(ZT) and installed the the newer version of zerodha trader.i am new to zerodha so i wish i will trade tom.
But newer version is showing the problem ” “NEST INITIALIZATION FAILED FOR IINTERACTION ENGINE:<> “..
thats why i am unable to log in to my account.
help me what should i do now?
open it ” run as administrator”
i have already tried this…!!
Do send all such account related queries directly to [email protected]
Hi Nitin ji
installed new version of zt and also updated nest update and plugin…. but still facing problems…
platfrom is crashing many times… which is causing trouble mentally and financially…
Eagerly waiting for the launch of pi… can u please tell us the exact date of the launch.. 1st week of jan is almost over, as u said.
* please if possible ad features like elliot wave, and different strategies as included in motive wave.
* if possible available data integrating from pi to amibroker/metastock.. if they can fetch data from pi to ami/meta.. resulting no data delay to them..
thanks !
This weekend we will release to between 500 to 1000 people. And over the course of next week, we will give it to all.
How do i apply for Pi ?
Dear Nithin,
In case a few of the clients currently using Pi (1.0.0.4) are not in the set of 500 – 1000 people to whom the next version will be released, would the 1.0.0.4 version of Pi be supported for the other users during the transition ? Am asking because I am a very active user of Pi for trading, and would not want to switch back to ZT and back again.
Alternately, is there a criteria selecting people for the limited roll-out ?
Best,
Senthil
The latest release has almost everything fixed, and we will give it out to everyone next week. We just want to see if everything behaves correctly when adding new users. Yes you can use 1.0.0.4 until then. No criteria as such, we plan to randomly pick 500 to 1000.
What is the criteria for this release?
Facing several issues with ZT on daily basis. Can’t wait to get back to Pi.
Just posted this: The latest release has almost everything fixed, and we will give it out to everyone next week. We just want to see if everything behaves correctly when adding new users. Yes you can use 1.0.0.4 until then. No criteria as such, we plan to randomly pick 500 to 1000.
today faced huge losses coz terminal hanged in the morning so not able to book profit… which later converted into loss… now zerodha mush pay me…
Gopal,i also faced the problem of software hanging in the morning.but i used call n trade facility immediately.so whenever the problem comes,always use there call n trade facility,
Gopal, today morning there was an issue from the exchange itself, where order confirmations were not coming through in time. It is best to send all account specific queries to [email protected]
thats no excuse.. ur co. is responsible for my loss… i was in abt 5k profit.. now i end up.. in abt 6k loss….. last 3-4 days earnings/hardwork all gone in vain…
your co. should have backtested before doing changes in ur server etc…
even today it crashed 10 time, how can somebody work in these condition…
i don know what to do now??
There was no issue today Gopal, and our server migration has happened long time ago. It is best if you put all your individual queries to [email protected]
Dear Nithin,
As you prepare for the final beta release, thought it would be better to mention a few basic issues in Pi (am sure they are already handled , but just in case):
1. Chart data backfill: The patch certainly reinstated backfill, but the last historical bar and the first new bar are not accurate. Equivolume charts’ rendering is quite off track with backfill data, so am assuming that even though the prices for all but the last bar is OK, there may be issues with volume data (looks like it gets aggregated). The charting itself is fine when only current data is used, so this just has to do with data I guess.
2. In the order window, once invoked using F1 on market watch, I am not able to change the instrument. Though the display shows the change, the order when placed, is the original instrument.
3. Occasionally, an order is rejected with a message “Server not ready” … faced this issue today after a long time.
4. Sometimes, when I login with the Quick Login checkbox unchecked, the Market Index does not appear.
5. In a saved market watch, index rows are not retained when we login again.
1,2, & 3 are the more critical ones – of which (2) has resulted in some serious situations.
All the best for the release. Looking forward to it.
Best,
Senthil (DS2929)
Hello Nithin, I am planning to open an account with you because of your Pi Terminal.
I want to know when it will be tradeable as i have already sent forms because my friend told me it is operating. Do let me know.
Thanks in advance and hatts off to you being an entrepreneur
-VS
Vipul, we had given the beta release to a few clients, but we will be putting up a new release by this weekend. Next week, we will slowly start releasing this to everyone.
Cheers,
Hi Nitin,
My only reason to open account with Zerodha was PI software that is going to get released out,So could you please let me know do i need to send a specific mail to some one to get it as early as early because as you mentioned that you will slowly start releasing to client from next week .
Thanks in advance .
We will send out info on this soon.
Thanks Nithin for your instant reply,
I will be starting trading also next week with you. I wish you all the good luck and good health 🙂
Thanks again. Wishes to Zerodha team
Hi Nitin,
any updates on Kite?
Hi, Nithin,
Is that
1. Automatic back-filling (and or) 2. Commodity Trading
available with Final Beta release?
Wishing you & Zerodha Team belated Happy & Prosperous New Year 2015.
1. Yes
2 .Yes
Happy new year.
Thank you so much.
Hallo Nithin Can We Use ZIGZAG Indicator For Algo Coding & back Testing in New PI ?
Hi,
I am unable to start PI since yesterday. I contacted support, they are saying they have upgraded servers and I have to wait till Monday to get new update. If that is the case, PI shouldn’t work for anybody.
Here is the message that pops up when I try to start PI:
Microsoft.NET Frame work
” Unhandled exception has occurred in a component in your application. If you click Continue, the application will ignore this error and attempt to continue.
Configuration system failed to initialize.”
I will appreciate it if anyone can guide me how to rectify this problem.
Thanks a lot.
Yes, we will have the new release out by this weekend. We are not supporting the older release.
hi nitin,
please include Donchain Channel Indicator on charts for intraday / positional trades in PI.
Hi Nithin,
Hope you are doing good.
I would like to use Pi this weekend. Send me the details pls. My zerodha ID : DR1974
HI NITHIN,
RECENTLY I OPENED AN ACCOUNT WITH ZERODHA(THIS WEEK).I WANNA SAY THAT I AM NOT HAPPY WITH YOUR COMPANY.EVERYTIME I HAVE TO CALL FOR CUSTOMER SUPPORT,TODAY I TRADED IN “”CURRENCY GBPINR” AND I DIDNT KNEW HOW TO CALCULATE THE PROFIT,I CALLED YOUR CUSTOMER CARE EXECUTIVE “RENU” AND “POONAM” THEY TOLD ME THAT THEY WILL ARRANGE A CALL FROM “CDS” DEPARTMENT WITHIN 5-10 MIN. I WAITED BUT I DIDNT GOT A CALL,UNFORTUNATELY AFTER SO MUCH TIME I HAVE TO CALL THEM AFTER 1 HOUR THAT HOW TO CALCULATE THE BROKERAGE. WHEN MY ACCOUNT WAS OPENED YOU TECHNICAL PERSON NEVER TOLD ME THAT “HOW TO PLACE A ORDER IN BRACKET AND COVER ORDER” AND DIDNT TOLD ME THAT AFTER PLACING A ORDER FOR “BO&CO” YOU HAVE TO GIVE “TRANSACTION AUTHENTICATION PASSWORD” THEY ALSO DIDNT TOLD ME.
WHATS WRONG WITH YOUR COMPANY AND WHY DONT YOU PROVIDE FULL INFORMATION.
I AM NOT HAPPY OPENING AN ACCOUNT WITH YOUR COMPANY.CAN I GET MY TRADING ACCOUNT MONEY BACK.
IT WILL BE HATTS OFF TO YOU IF YOU REFUND MY MONEY.
I DONT WANNA DO TRADING WITH YOUR COMPANY.
EARLIER MY ALL DOCUMENTS WAS RECEIVED AT YOUR OFFICE BEFORE A/C OPENED I TOLD THEM THAT I DONT WANNA OPEN AN A/C,UNFORTUNATELY I AM REGRETTING THAT.
I WANT MY TRADING MONEY BACK.I DONT WANNA TRADE WITH YOUR COMPANY.
CLIENT ID :- DA2880.
1. zerodha is best in market with low brokerage and service. some times unexpected problems arise. and also revolution in industry. this my personal experience.
Shankar i have seen on thing..whenever client complaint about zerodha.,””CEO OF ZERODHA NITHTIN KAMATH “” DONT REPLY..HE TRIES TO STAY AWAY FROM THE ISSUES RATHER THAN LISTENING TO THE CLIENT.
NITHIN JUST GIVES REPLY TO NORMAL QUES.!!! I WANNA KNOW WHAT HAPPENED TO NITHIN NOW. ITS NOT THAT SOMETIMES PROBLEM ARISE BUT EVERYTIME YOU HAVE TO CALL THEIR PAID CUSTOMER SUPPORT,I AM FEELING GUILTY THAT I OPENED ACCOUNT WITH ZERODHA.HUH! PAID CUSTOMER SUPPORT.
Hey Akash, If you are trading currency futures, you should do it only if you know how to. We as Zerodha offer you an execution platform with all the tools. Our business model doesn’t let us give you a dedicated RM who can teach you what currency trading is, and etc. We have never said that we will give such kind of support anywhere. But if you are interested, most answers to your question is already available on Z-connect, you just have to search for it. I guess you also know that I run a decent size business, so I am not on Zconnect all the time answering queries. If you have any trading queries, ask on Zconnect or tradingqna, and if it is specific to your account send it [email protected]. If your expectation from us was something else, and you want to withdraw funds, login to Q.zerodha.com and you can place the fund withdrawal request.
Best of luck.
Dude,
1. First of all this thread is about Pi and related topics,not personal complaint thread.
2. STOP WRITING IN CAPS.
3.You said ,you had to wait for one hour for them to answer.Apparently it could have been well spent actually going to Zerodha website and in the clicking http://zerodha.com/brokerage_calculator link.
4.You should have gone through “How to place Order” threads in Z-Connect.Seriously ,give them a break!
5. Wow,they have to tell you to put in transaction password which you set up earlier when you initially installed NEST.What do you think that password was for?
6.I am not even sure what money you are asking? Account opening charges or the money YOU transferred to the trading account which you can withdraw at any time.Why the nagging?
Although Zerodha facing problems in many aspects but come on!!
I should not comment.. but .. I like below statement :-
“DIDNT TOLD ME THAT AFTER PLACING A ORDER FOR “BO&CO” YOU HAVE TO GIVE “TRANSACTION AUTHENTICATION PASSWORD” THEY ALSO DIDNT TOLD ME.”
Does any guy from google told you to give password while using gmail ? 😀
Don’t Mind..Just kidding!!
Enjoy 🙂
i mean there technical person never told me that after you place order,a tab will come that will ask you transation authentication password.seriously i didnt knew my authentication password.so i called their Paid Customer Support that its asking for transaction authentication password then they send me temporary authentication password..after that i changed it,..just because of it i was unable to trade..they are just FRAUD AND MISGUIDING THE PEOPLE.
FEELING THAT I OPENED AN ACCOUNT WITH ZERODHA.
WHERE IS CEO OF ZERODHA NITHIN GONE.. WHY IS HE TODAY NOT REPLYING..
I WANT MY TRADING MONEY BACK.
NITHIN DO YOU HAVE GUTS TO REFUND MY MONEY?
Akash,
I had a good laugh reading your complaint . You seem to be from other planet just landed here.
I have high respect for Nithin ( of course he can do better). His mistake here is that he made this forum so open allowing th
kars,
apni maa ki kasam khaa..kitne paise diye hai nithin ne tuje ye comment likhne ke liye?
And to add on to what I have written above, I am looking at your trading details, you had traded on 6th as well. So my guess is that you already knew about transaction password. You haven’t traded GBPINR, so I really don’t know what your issue is. And if there is anything, do send it to [email protected], zconnect is not the place to discuss any of your account related queries.
yes,thats what i am talking about..when your technical person has given me a demo,then at that time why he didnt told me about “Transaction authentication password” and never told me at that sir you have to put a request for enabling bracket order.is he was sleeping at that time.why he didnt give me full information,if you are watching my trading details,then tap the voice also while he has given me demo that he didnt give me full information.
If your trading one should know transaction pass is mandatory, its set by the sebi and has to followed by broker. its a security feature to protect your trading .
i cant stop laughing the way you are complaining here in this forum..very kiddish
Akash,
I could not resist myself writing this as a response just to make aware to “tribesmen who don’t know how to interact on a social platform”
Understand that just having Money in bank + A Trading account + Bookish knowledge + 0 researching capability = will not sustain this market.
Reading Trading for Dummies should not be your last trading book !!
You better practice on a demo account before you blow up your capital.
(Mark this date)
Why the fuss over just a transaction password and trying to blame everyone from support to CEO. What was your logical thinking saying at that point?
I thought your key board had a problem and now I know it is your anger.
If you don’t control anger you will never be able to trade without anxiety for the rest of your life.
What is use of that money, when it is going towards Dr expenses!!!
*I can sense that you have very high possibility of revenge trading and wiping out your account clean( Don’t go by Modiji’s word for this –swachh bharat abhiyan)
*You would be very soon depressed when a trade goes against you and so is the next day and next trade.
*People are put into stress around you
Best of luck, get a crash course from babypips.com and lot of demo trading or a much better hobby
zerodha is lies every time when ask for pi launch date
when i call zerodha for account open 2 months back they tell pi will launch in 2 to 3 days
NITHIN please answer that
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8aJBJdm1EzE
JAPJIT,
eh zerodha wale jhuth hee bolna jaande hor ehna nu aaanda ki hai..ek no. de farzi bande ne eh..nov. toh bolde aa rahe ne mainu lgda..jan. aagya hje tak ta ehna zerodha pi release nhi ho rahi…
That video is hilarious :), but seriously speaking launching a trading software is not an easy task. We have over 1000 people testing out Pi, I guess that is when you opened an account with us. We had to delay the launch because some of the fixes took longer than expected. We will start giving out the final beta release of Pi in batches of 500 to 1000 from Monday onwards.
Cheers,
I have been trading from zerodha from 2010 & i didnt face any issue till now as this the best brokerage firm and Nitin is aware of his business model and to take off.
Please reduce brokerage as you have earned much.
I would like to use Pi this weekend. Send me the details pls. My zerodha ID : Dr0875
Akash is just a new bie to trading & didnt go through the demo & research as he is trading in currency without researching his platform
ravi,
i asked for the solution for nithin kamath, so dont interfare in my matter.dude,do your work,got it? you are trading from 2010,did i asked you? its just shows duplicacy to hide the face.hope you understand what i mean.
Dear Akash Kheterpal, kindly stop abusing Zeodha & Nitin. It seems that you are unaware of trading and are also facing some personal trauma. Kindly visit a psychiatrist for a resolution. And as Nitin already mentioned above, withdraw your funds and be at peace with yourself. Have a nice day…
Dear Priyesh,
Dont you have manner calling your dad that you are facing personal trauma.
Nithin,
When are you finally launching Pi? Was it not supposed to be the first week of Jan?
How to get Pi Software.. First week of Jan is over but it is still not viewable anywhere
We will inform soon, we will start releasing it out from next week. You will have a link available on Q for getting Pi.
dear nithin ji
is it possible ( not now ,but in future) to view SGX NIFTY in our pi.
No Vinesh, we don’t get data feeds from SGX.
When will CO/BO be available on web platform? Will it be only IE…or Firefox will also be supported?
Thanks
Our new web platform is called Kite, and it can be used on all browsers. Yes, it will have CO/BO, but no timeline yet on when it will be launched.
Dear Nithin ji,
From past one month, i stopped my trading and waiting for PI updated beta version.Now i get only market watch on PI. So please provide me PI beta in the first phase in your next release.
I agree with your comments that, creating a good trading cum charting plotform is not a easy task. I know so many technical issues to be resolve to run it accurately and effectively.
As aware of your/zerodha commitment and professionalism towards customers benefit and your efforts to provode great tools to your customers to their trading edge, i understand how you put great efforts to fixes problems in PI. But i know it takes some time. Its a crucial time to zerodha.
In a individual or company career, we may face some struggles or obstacles. its a temporary. it can teach us some lessons to evolve to more better in our tasks.Not ready PI in stipulated time, temporarily create some discomforts to traders at zerodha.
But i have a great confidence in zerodha. A great future ahead to zerodha and its customers. Good luck to zerodha and Nithin bhai.
MY ID; DC0292.
Having Pi out, is probably more important for us as a business than any of our clients. We are desperate to have it out as soon as possible, we don’t want to push it this time and compromise.
Hey Nithin,
A quick query on Pi MT4 bridge..I understand that its not a priority for u guys now, but do you have a timeline in mind for its support ? or it isnt in your plate of TODOs right now ?
+ Data feed for MT4…I suggest you guys include this as an expansion of your products and provide that..( after all you must be entitled to redistribute the data that you might be feeding to your servers.. I assume you are using Globaldatafeeds)
Wrt Pi..do we have a method to reconcile to data that is not updated due to power failure / internet disconnectivity ? Method to export tick data / Historical data to csv ?
My ZT trader not working. i have downloaded as fresh exe from zerodha, but not working now. is there any other links?
Send an email to [email protected]
mail sent already, is Pi is allocated for me?
Muthu, we are making a few changes in how we give out Pi. We will share the details on it soon.
sir i want to know is pi have only charts like nest plus or it has some feature of charting software like list of gainers on high vol low vol and other things like that
i mean can we use it as modrate tech charting software
Yep it has quite advanced charting features. Check this
Hi Nitin,
First of all Very Very Happy & Profitable New Year to you and all our zerodha family
I am egarly waiting when i am use Pi software
any release date of the same
And last but not least Thanks for your energetic efforts
Thanks Kantilal, we are hoping to have the first few clients to start trading on it from monday. But we will slowly scale this up next week, monitoring the performance.
Commitment is more important Mr. Nithin. Wetting for Pi, release fast as soon as possible. Thanks.
Nitin,
I believe that release of Pi is stretching a bit too far. It is testing our patience. We have very little trust in ZT now.
Cheers
9th Jan 2015
So we are almost ready to launch the “final beta release of Pi” from monday, 12th Jan. If everything works well, we will have the final release of Pi within the next 3 weeks. For all those who have used the previous beta and given us feedback, it has taken us over 2 months to incorporate most of what you had requested for.
1. We did a complete upgrade of trading servers last month, so the performance has gone up significantly.
2. We have upgraded the servers that send data to the charts, so NSE, NFO, and Currency charts, will probably match up to data of the most expensive data providers in the country. Also adding indicators, drawing tool bar, and all issues around it has been fixed.
3.All exchanges: NSE, BSE, and MCX are live.
4. We have created a screen to log all your alerts from Expert advisors, Scripted alerts, and Pi bridge, for semi automated trading. Clicking on the alert places an order.
5. Pi bridge is live for amibroker. We are working on having the bridge to MT4 soon.
6. Issues around saving layouts is fixed.
7. You will have 1 year of intraday data for the top 200 stocks and indices. We will slowly add more stocks to the list. You will be able to load upto 50,000 candles on a single chart.
Bracket orders will take a little longer. Also, we presently have minute and hourly charts. End of day charts, will take few more days.
We are going to start releasing Pi from monday, we will release it only to a few for the first 2 or 3 days, and slowly increase the pace.
To enable Pi:
1. From monday, you will see a Pi icon in Q(https://q.zerodha.com/). The ID’s that we had previously enabled for beta of Pi, won’t work from monday, you will have to put a new request.
2. You will have an option to request for beta of Pi when clicked on the icon. We will be giving this beta only to our active client base, (clients who have generated atleast Rs 300 of brokerage over the last 30 days). If you are not our active client, you will have to wait until the final release.
3. Once you place a request, you will get a download link, and a key. The download link, also has a readme doc, that explains the installation process. We have simplified the installation process quite a bit. Four clicks and you should be ready.
4. Once you have done this, you will be notified on the same page when your login is enabled for trading on Pi on the same page in Q. How fast this happens will depend on the queue, and the speed at which we are releasing licenses.
5. The link to enable “Pi bridge” to connect to Amibroker for semi-automated trading will be available by next weekend on the same page in Q.
Note: It is still the final “Beta” version, so if you spot any issues do let us know. I will put up a blogpost with video on monday to run a quick overview of latest beta release of Pi.
I understand this has gotten delayed quite a bit and having Pi out soon is quite important for us as a business. We hit multiple roadblocks along the way, hopefully as they say, ” Patience is bitter, but its fruit is sweet”.
Happy Trading,
Appreciate your work Nithin..
I still have an objection to make.. I may not be an active trader according to your logs.. i was testing out my strategies and just when i started executing, your critical update and things happened.. from that day, issue of freezing of ZT took over.. When a terminal freezes 6-8 times everyday, how is a new trader supposed to be active.. and that too when your support dept didn’t have any answer for that.. i was hoping i could become active but now it seems i’ll have to wait three more weeks which is a bit unfair.. may be, you ppl will have a log of clients who complained about ZT freezing.. you can enable Pi for those clients even if they were inactive.. i guess i’m not the only one with this case here.. please consider it..
my client id is DJ9517..
thank you..
Hi Nithin,
I guess Nest chart issue started on Nov 5 after their update to V 2.9.0.0 and ZT problem started on 5 Dec after the critical update ,so for the past 2 months many of the active traders probably stopped trading with these issues,So giving Pi based on active clients is not fair.
And for people, who recently opened their accounts also would probably waiting for Pi to start their trading so they cant qualify as active trader,please give preference to them.
Previously you told Pi will be randomly given to 500 – 1000 clients, now you came up with this active client criteria. I can understand that Pi will be out to everyone slowly may be of scalability issues.But it will be fine if the system randomly select clients rather than this “active client” thing.
Thanks
Nithin, since you were a trader, lets see this from a traders’ perspective.
inactive traders are a different story. but traders rendered inactive due to a frequently hanging trading terminal are entirely a different story.
if you were providing a smooth terminal all along and say that only active people will get pi, it is justifiable, acceptable and others will continue with their existing one.
what we were provided was a frequently hanging/stopping/freezing/whatever terminal to which the technical department had no answers whatsoever.to trade with such a terminal itself needs a separate skillset and temperament. and still you expect people to be active.
Come on. look from reality point of view. if the terminal was faulty beyond repair, is it fair to pin the blame on the trader for being inactive? and if it happened for few days or a week, your stand might be acceptable. instead it is nearly two months.
Can you accept if you were in our position?.. will you waste three more weeks just because the brokerage house could not identify or rectify the problem with your existing terminal? while others who were lucky to have their ZT functional get Pi in addition.
even after reading this, if you still feel justified with your stand, please give us an answer how should we trade until we get Pi. and three weeks is no mean timeframe. For the first time i feel let down by you.
BTW i donot want to take the credit away from you. you guys do an excellent job and ZT before strip down & update was very nice. it will be nice after Pi release. but you owe us an answer, for us who ZT poses problems.
thank for launching pi bata
i want know which email i have to send request ?
or any link
I have just posted a comment above
Do consider our request the reason i opened a trading account with you guys was because of pi and now you say we have to wait for 3 more weeks i think this is a bit unfair trading on ZT is a bit difficult !!! Do consider this !!! My demat was opened on 6th jan !!! Don’t make us wait like this !!
Hi ,
Only reason opening the account with Zerodha was that u r providing the PI software , if still I need to wait for another 3 week or so then its totally useless for me because I am also having trading account with 1 more discount whose charges are similar to of yours and have been trading with them for last 2 years , I opened another account just for PI
So it would be great for us if u could remove this condition for distributing the software
Thanks
@RK, Sutha, Jana, Rahul, Shashank,
Firstly, we should hopefully have it released for all much before 3 weeks. Since we have extended the deadlines the last time around, I am just being safe.
Secondly, we have to give priority, and as a business we have to give it those who are trading with us before we give it those who aren’t or haven’t yet. Yes we had issues in December when we did the server upgrade, so it makes it even more important for us to give priority to those who traded with us during that time.
Also, we have put a lot of resource and fire power behind Pi. We won’t let the mistake that Sharekhan did, everyone was using their charting/resources for free, and trading with some other brokerage (They just woke up now, and charge I guess for Trade tiger, which gets adjusted with brokerage, Rs 10,000/year).
If during the next week there is no issue in scaling the number of licenses, we will have most of you using Pi much, much before 3 weeks.
Happy weekend
I understand.. but tell me how am i supposed to trade till then.. if you had provided me a solution for the problem ZT is posing right now, i wouldn’t have been here in the first place.. Doesn’t this amount to deficiency of service?. What answer do you have for the issue of freezing of ZT?. its like saying ‘look mate, we couldn’t sort out your problem.. so wait till we see if people with no problem face any problem’..
and for your comparison with sharekhan, people accustomed to zerodha will find it hard to trade or move on with some other brokerages.. that is why i’m still here reasoning with you and i’ll be with you..
Jana, there are no freezing issues on ZT. There were issues for a few days last month when we did the upgrade. ZT has been working quite well over the last month. I will get someone to call you back and see where you are facing any issues on ZT.
Thank you for writing to Zerodha.
We have also come across this issue from our few other customers too, our developers are working on it, and we are hoping a speedy solution on the same. Until then, we thank you for your patience and cooperation.
If you have any queries please do write to us or you can also call us on 080-40402020.
this was the response your guys gave on 19/12/2014 for the issue i reported..please refer my to support tickets.. i had attached snapshots too.. if you still need it, i’ll attach monday’s snapshot when it happens..
Wow!!!!
“Learn from the mistakes of others… you can’t live long enough to make them all yourselves!!”
#Sharekhan 😛
Learn from a lot of our own mistakes, and from others as well I guess. ;)… The thing is, if you don’t risk being wrong/commit mistakes, very tough to be progressive.
Hi Nithin,
Currently I have a trading account with SBI I want to open a account in Zerodha soon. I have a doubt with respect with options. Do you have any tool in your option trading platfrom where i can build A Option strategy and execute a trade in one go. Like buying and writing calls at different strike prices ex spreads, coz the overall margin requirement for a option spread is lower than for a individual put or call.
For now you can use Basket orders and Spread orders. But note that even in these order types, orders are sent individually, so the margin benefit you get on multi-leg option strategy kicks in only after taking a particular position. To enter the position you will still need the complete margins upfront. You could use our SPAN calculator to know the margins upfront.
Understand your concern about misuse of Zerodha’s liberalism. Yet, Please consider giving inactive traders other options – like, pay and use your tools as in eg: trade tiger. For beginners it is important to watch the market, learn the tool and do some mock trading before putting real money on the line. Hope you give Pi to everyone after the release, thats fine; or else the policy of limiting usage to active traders only is going to be a spirit dampener. Hope Zerodha comes out with an mutually agreeable strategy which is.
Yes Sham, we will come up with a plan for that (Rs 300 to Rs 500 per month, which gets adjusted with brokerage). If no trades happen, that becomes like a platform usage fees. We will have this up soon for our inactive clients.
Wont this be possible ? Give Pi free for everyone for a month or 2, let everyone understand it and be confident trading markets; then u can start the charges against brokerage as planned. Seriously u need to give inactive clients and newbies a chance to use Pi. Thanks.
Yes we will in the next 2 weeks. We plan to charge an upfront Rs 300 to Rs 500/month, which gets adjusted with brokerage. If no trades, it becomes a platform usage charge.
I completely agree with you nithin Let’s say a client has 10000 in their trading account collateralize the platform fee and start giving it to us in case they don’t generate commissions you get to keep the fee or else if they do you end up getting your commissions anyway !!!
Nithin,
i want that Zerodha should also start unlimited monthly brokerage plan,are you also working on it?
No Akash, we are not looking at any monthly brokerage plans.
hi,
i have just started trading. i have rs 28000 in my account.
i trade approx once daily mainly through the android app maybe once or twice a month through zt.last 30 days generated around 120 in brokerage.was really looking forward to pi.dont mind waiting few days but i am a little confused about the fee which was never mentioned before.will the fee be for tools or for the whole platform instead?cant you waive the fee for accounts with more than 25000 rs?have no other account with any other broker so little hard to misuse pi.please clarify
cheers,
da2256
Aditya we have spent a lot on infra and our running costs are quite high for Pi, especially for streaming data to power the charts. The quality of data that you will see on pi, will probably match up very close to esignal which charges over 10k a month to use it. So to ensure that atleast the cost of running the platform is covered, we are saying that we will give it to only those who are generating atleast Rs 300 brokerage per month. Very soon we will give an option, where you can pay this Rs 300 upfront which gets adjusted with brokerage for the month. If you don’t trade anything for the month, the Rs 300 will end up as a platform usage fees. So technically speaking there is no fees for using Pi. Pi is the desktop application, there is no mobile version of it.
Hi,
As far as mail from Siva goes ,he mailed me that I would be getting Pi on 12th jan.From the look of it,probably won’t be happening.No point crying over spilled milk.
Paying fees for using Pi would be acceptable,but then I hope payment gateway would be smooth and Pi would be enabled much quicker than “email and wait” process.
The problem is for those of us who have already paid costly data packages and now need to trade compulsorily or fork up data cost again for Pi.My current annual subscription for real time data still has 5 months at least.So,its a bit messy for us right now who actually has rtd package.Thank god I didn’t subscribe for F&O and MCX.
Secondly, if usage of Pi is charged, people will clamour for heads if server goes down.Hope Zerodha is aware of that.
For those who are scalpers it is absolutely important to trade from chart.So Pi would have solved the problem beautifully.But awaiting three weeks is a buzzkill and probably won’t be trading ZT cause opening ZT and RTD chart is a problem in laptop screen.
Active traders who already beta tested has got a feel of Pi.But please release it to dormant(?) traders as quickly possible.And before charging fees please allow at least two months time after releasing Pi.
Riddhi, we are not charging fees for PI, Pi is still free of cost. We are just saying that the client has to be an active trader with us. Rs 300 of brokerage a month, that is like the cost of 4 plates of Dosa in a Darshini in Bangalore today. Like I was saying, the last time around we realized that most of our time was spent answering and supporting people who hadn’t placed a trade with us also.
There is no payment gateway and all, if Rs 300 is not generated, at the end of the month the difference between Rs 300 and brokerage paid will be debited. Yes we will try to give this to everyone as fast as possible.
Dear Riddhi,
As far as I understand what Nitin is saying is that they will release PI to those who are generating them brokerage of at least Rs 300 brokerage per month. Now this means that a trader who is doing only 15 trades a month will get Pi on priority and those who are not that active may give Rs 300 upfront which will be adjusted against their use.
Thus, you can understand that Zerodha is not charging any thing extra. So don’t worry. If you are subscribing advanced feeds then you must be a very active trader. So you should get Pi without any upfront payment.
As trader we should give a big thumbs up to the Zerodha team. We have high hopes from Pi.
Cheers.
Hi, Nithin,
Rs 300 brokerage per month is small amount for most of traders, no problem. But a month consists of only about 20 trading days, so u can think of little flexible options also in longer term like:-
1. Rs 600 for 2 month,
2. Rs 900 for 3 month (or like 60 day challenge, 60 trading days which is about 3 month).
Active traders would not bother to choose 3 month scheme as they generate thousands of brokerage for you in small time. But in that case they don’t have to pay per month charge for any inactive month(say 1 month holiday 🙂 ). They can trade more peacefully with 3 month plan.
Please think of it & give us longer term option also.
With all good wishes for PI.
H.C.
Ya Nithin
I too am a bit concerned about this.
What if an active trader is unable to trade for a month due to some reason?
Will his rating of being an active trader till the previous month is going to get in vain just because of current month’s in-activeness? (I think that will be a bit unfair).
Wouldn’t it be wise and fair if you let trader to activate and deactivate the use of PI for any particular month?
If he choose to use Pi for a particular month then he will be charged.
And if not then he can use ZT without any charge.
Mr Nithin
I think small traders should say good by ,if he is not a day trader.Shall there be any other platform for small traders ?.Should we pay for Kite also?
Yes it seems that way. Small traders must generate volumes now to pay for Pi software or keep using ZT. Freeze, restart…. freeze…restart…. and on…………………..
I am a day trader who is still still learning the system and money management, So i’m still trading with very small quantities, I trade a maximum of 10k to 30k per day. So last month i might have generated a brokerage of 50 rupees or less. I am using Diet odin for charts and placing trades through Zerodha trader. The problem i had during beta phase of pi was, after logging in though Pi and then opening Diet odin, i could not see the charts in Odin, i had to re-install Odin to see charts again. So there is some conflict between Pi and Diet odin.
For people trading futures they will easily generate a brokerage of 300 rupees with only a single trade everyday.
Anyway, i was hoping to use Pi but won’t get a chance as i have not been generating 300 rs brokerage/month. But last time, i was the one who pointed the inaccurate intraday charts of Pi with pictures. I proved to be a useful beta tester and looks like my feedback has been implemented based on the notes i read.
hi nitin,
please give weightage to the mt4 bridge , the faster this feature is released and hopefully it works without bugs it will be a big boost for traders.
Mr. Nithin, I preferred Zerodha over SAS online or Trade smart online which were much cheaper brokerage firm. Don’t you think It will be a burden on the small traders head paying 300 Rs or more monthly. Cant it be avoided ? I Think , Pi is capable of generating enough brokerage from the traders uses charting software while trading. Anyway I hope you will choose the best possible way in favor of your traders.
I along with your thousands of traders demand to provide us daily and weekly view on market so that we could have an idea to decide the direction of our trades. You should provide a good technical analyst to your over 40000 customers .
Regards
Fazlur rehman
Like I have clearly mentioned, we are not charging anything. All that we are saying till now is, the first set of clients who will be given access to the final beta release of Pi will be those who are active with us. Very soon we will give access to everyone (even if you are dormant).
Dear Nithin ,
I would like point out few things ,
1.lets start with your one comment “I was saying, the last time around we realized that most of our time was spent answering and supporting people who hadn’t placed a trade with us also. “Though I am a active trader (I generated 5645 rs from sep to dec and total brokerage with all the taxes was around 11 k)
2. I would like to say why would I place an order over ZT with limited features and Pi which was not working. As a scalper I mainly depends on the charts . After the critical update ZT terminal was working fine most of days . But charting in ZT was barred from any indicators , and zoom in ( a basic feature) was limited . Now I will be using ZT to place an order only and to see NSE, BSE THE LIVE TICKER) . You know Nithin I can actually see those data in my windows mobile NSE app. 🙂
3. Nithin you are a dynamic CEO , I love you for that . Those who place trade ZT last month either they are having another platform to look at the charts or they are purely gambling . 🙂 I dont have any other platform to look at the charts . So why I would take the risk of gambling (I know You need luck and timing in trading also still ) as I am a scalper.
4. All those 45 – 50 k people who are in Zerodha family are not HNI , superactive traders I guess (I may be wrong ) . Most of them like your business policy . You brought a revolution “Discount Brokerage ” others are following you steps. Zerodha became so popular because you listen to the people and caters their needs . And you know Nithin in this market panics a lot , it applies to Zerodha family members also . When Pi was not working and at the same time ZT crashed you I panicked , like me lot of other people they must have panicked . I lost 40k . I appreciate that You told us that you will refund the brokerage and You have done it , but I lost 40k because of this technical glitch. So Nithin I will not put my hard earned money over a faulty trading system. Now as per you those who didnt put their hard earned money (again I dont have any other trading platform , I didnot have that amount of money to buy expensive live data feeds ) they are inactive trading . And who must be a gambler or have other trading platform as they have more money are active traders !!!
5. About you comment on Sharekhan ,
Sharekhan is a full time old brokerage house , they have their own HNI’s and lot of small time retail investor and traders have paid a huge amount of money as (costly brokerage ) , but Zerodha’s business model are totally different from Sharekhan , You are Discount broker (a life saver for the small retail investors and traders ) . Zerodha’s CEO replies to all the members and few non members ( people loves you for that ) . People , I love you because You reply to all the queries . You fair in your business . You know there are few more Discount Brokerage houses offers same brokerage or than You . Still I am with you because of the love for Zerodha . For You Nithin . Thats the only reason people are joining you . Because others are offering Nest , almost same brokerage . So when you said “…..spent answering and supporting people who hadn’t placed a trade with us also. ” I felt little bad . People , I will place trade if we got the basic things are working fine . ZT ‘s chart was untraceable ad the indicators were not there . If You had given them the OLD ZT with all the charts and indicators I dont think that you could ever say this active or inactive traders . 🙂
6. Now Pi , I have beta tested it and it was a refreshing experience until that D-day when you upgraded your servers and everything went wrong . Now you are saying people have to generate 300rs as a brokerage for a month . That counts 3600 rs brokerage a year . Say I dont use Pi for placing a order (or generate your mentioned brokerage) for a year , I will be qualified as a in active trader so I have to pay 3600rs as a platform using fee ! What do you say I am occasional trader and I do mainly investing as your brokerage charges are competitive , for investing also I do need to look at the historical and weekly charts of the particular stock , He/she has to pay for the trading platform uses charge . Dont say he/she can use kite , trade.zerodha or ZT , as they either dont have charting and ZT charting is unspeakable . So that that investor has to pay max 20 rs+ stt and other charges + platform uses charges !!!!! I think again a panic will start spreading . 🙂 For a trading scalper like me its oki , but for positional trader , occasional trader it will be a costly affair. Your platform usage charge alone will make you a moderately charged brokerage house.
7. Now before charging upfront money or your desired brokerage ,
a . First make Pi a stable trading platform. Let the traders regain confidence on Pi.
b. Let it run on all the traders desktop and take the feedback .
c. Do the final release bug free .Make it popular . Add all the indicators .
d. Pi should not be a resource monger application , make it right .
e. In Your blog when you were reply to a member , You wrote we have miles to go to catch Ninja trader or MT4 . By God’s grace You and your dream child Pi will be there one day . When Pi will be very powerful trading platform , that day will you charging us for platform use like the Sharekhan 10000k 😛 or may be more that that 😛
I know making trading software is not a easy and you are burdened by a huge infra cost and You were bog down by many unavoidable circumstances . You did a personal apology for that I respect you for that . I know that it was not you fault , You are great leader . Keep the spirit . I will tell my friends to trade and investing on Zerodha if this business continues (By Gods grace ,I hope that it will ) . These increasing number of love and membership towards Zerodha will compensate your huge infra cost . Always remember we , I love you and Your Zerodha for your business model and the interaction I can have with you . We love you , just dont forget us . 🙂 .
:), Thanks George. We will figure out something soon. We could probably have a condition saying if a client has X amount of funds in his account, he is an active client for us. But like you said, we want to first ensure that Pi is working properly over the next week.
Good night.
If everything goes well with Pi those people who were not trading they will be coming back and lots of new member will also come 🙂 We all know that you have a business to run and mouths to feed … 🙂
Excellent 🙂 say , those who have 5 – 10k in their account they are active trader/investor …..
dear nithin ji
i am very much impressed with the words of mr george P in above post, i do very much feel in my heart same love and respect for zerodha and you , not because of your brokerage ,but because of your prompt reply , care for client ,and eagerness to resolve the problem of your clients. which is 3-4 steps behind in other brokers . so please don’t let these things meshed with others. A TRUE LEADER DO NOT COMPARE ITSELF WITH OTHERS.
in respect of your defination of ACTIVE TRADER i have some points , and suggestion .
please have a look on these two cases
CASE 1= small trader/new trader= open a trade in ZINCM/LEADM/COPPERM/NICKELM/SLIVERMIC and square it before market close ,
frequency = daily one trade
trades in month=10-12 DAYS in a month
total turnover = 20-25 lac
brokerage generated= rs 250 (as per your brokerage calculator)
CASE 2= swing trader = open a trade in market on MONDAY- TUESDAY in 10 LOTS of NIFTY and square it on THU-FRI and spend a happy weekend with family
frequency= 1-2 trade weekly
trades in month=whole month
total turnover= 2-2.5 crore
brokerage generated =rs 240 ( for 6 trade)
both traders are full time traders in market but not able to generate RS 300 , so how would you call them that they are not active . in my knowledge the previous defination of active trader by you was that ACTIVE TRADER = those who open 5 trades in a month with you,
so , my suggestion is that please do not stuck with generation of RS 300 only ,please provide some more flexiblity in the defination of active trader, like that
ACTIVE TRADER= THOSE WHO
1> generate minimum brokerage of RS 250 per month
2> trade 10 days with you
3> maintain 15-20k balance in his trading a/c
FULLFILL ANY ONE CRITERIA WILL BE ACTIVE TRADER
please consider my views in this respect.
i also want to say that putting some condition for the use of a software which is still in its infancy is not good , let it used by existing users , develop it , make it powerful,bugfree,let it grow and then put some condition.
BUT any how , if you do not agree with my points then this is my humble request to you to reduce initial condition of RS 300 brokerage cum software charges to RS 200-250 to qualify us active trader
So, whats the final word on Pi for atleast timebeing. Who will get to use it and for what?????
This week, we will be taking it a little slow, and we will be giving it to our active clients. Hopefully in the next couple of weeks we should give it to everyone. We have always tried to keep the business simple, 1 brokerage plan, 1 RMS rule, Same deal for everyone. The last thing we would want to do is to put conditions like minimum brokerage and all. But that said, we would want to somehow ensure that the person who is using Pi is trading with us whatever be the frequency. So yeah, like George said, probably put a condition saying your account should have a X balance. Let us see, we will come up with something tomorrow.
huh… I know… I will get disqualified, just because of “X balance” 😮 😀 😀 😀 😛
and do I need to care about it??? 🙂 🙂
Dear Ramdas Ji , You dont need to feel scary , this x balance you can use for trading also , 🙂 I hope that Nithin will keep this x amount nominal … As Nithin has clearly told 1 brokarage , 1 RMS plan , from his above posts you can clearly see he encouraging you to do trade more with Pi ….. dont worry Nithin knows better than anyone of here who is a active trader …. a person may do trading daily like a scalper or he may do trading every 4 – 5 days like a swing / positional trader …. Or he/she may be an investor who use Pi just look at the performance of the equity …. NIthin knows this well …. Keep the trust on him …….End of the day he made Pi for us and spend a hefty amount to build Pi …. if you are not using Pi or taking the advantage Pi’s charting and placing trade on some other terminal whats the point of making Pi … I am requesting Nithin please release it everyone and hope that Pi will be bug free this time ….. Then you also dont need to worry THEM …. 🙂
We are all are doing businesses here . Point is how lovingly and how supportive we are to each other. Zerodha needs us likewise we also need Zerodha , like a family. Its not a one day affair . Happy trading . 🙂
🙂 🙂 🙂
Hi,
I used to be a very active day trader on zerodha. But when I visited the trading platform yesterday after some months, I found that the user interface….if I may so ….of the charts have changed. Earlier it used to be a black background but now it is white and looks boring. So can I still access the old interface where the charts had a black background.
Thanks
Manu, Omnesys/Reuters the vendors of NEST have stopped supporting Nest Plus, and hence the previous version is not available. We will start giving out Pi to everyone very soon.
DR875
I am a active trader from 2010 if your charging 300 rs for software I dont think your discounted broker as if you consider that around 100000-300000 users in zerodha you would earn 300*300000+ Brokerage which is unfavourable & you pay to servers & esignal data very low cost. Very soon you can see dormant accounts lying in Zerodha. Advanced broking terminals are going to come in india very soon.
I would switch to other broker with free of cost terminal as analysis part only does the terminal not the order part.
Hope you understand that generating income from market is very tuff after brokerage itsellf & adding to a cost of 3600 as your AMC charge for terminal.
Its seems not a right model to go with.
Rkglobal was charging with 300 rs for ODIN & 100rs for webbased but there price changes are very quicker than your & also mobile version is very good compared to ZT.
Mohan
Ravi you wont be charged if you generate Rs. 300 worth of Brokerage per month.
Release me DS3412 Pi Please
Thants a lot.
Release please Pi for DS3412
Thanks a lot.
Hi Nitin
Could you please facilitate for the Pi updated version as i am waiting since there is some upgradation in Pi. I have already forwarded the request to rms team.
thanks.
Dear nitin
Please tell me how to get PI
How to request for Pi? There is no link/ button on Q as informed earlier.
Hope its not delayed further.
I still havent got link in Q…. Please activate Pi
Watching Pi movie while waiting for Pi software release, eating my apple pie , hope to hear soon by 22/7 (π) time.
Still waiting on the link to be enabled and reading about Pi
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pi
The record for memorizing digits of π, certified by Guinness World Records, is 67,890 digits, recited in China by Lu Chao in 24 hours and 4 minutes on 20 November 2005
Dear , Sir
Please tell me how to get PI Link
MY Client ID is RY0132
Dear Mr. Nithin,
This is regarding Pi I want to inform you that I am generating brokerage more than your said limit. and you admin people keep on promising that I will get the PI before 12th. Now they are telling that I will get the NEW REQUEST FORM AFTER TWO DAYS. This is NOT acceptable at all. I closed my trading account from my previous broker and Joind Zerodha after seeing the demo of PI. But I am disappointed. Kindly do the needful ND GET ME pi IMMEDIATLY.
REgards
Anantha Raman
RA2465
where i need to check PI link… client code RM1068
Not able to find the download link in q.zerodha.com as posted. Please update status and link.
Jimmy
RJ0678
Nitin I think it is time to scrap Pi . its disgusting Zerodha keep promising Pi release of just few days ahead.
We have given it to around 50 people for now. If everything is alright, we will start releasing it to more number of people soon.
Dear nitin
Please make able PI on my I’d RC0258 .I m waiting for many day without trading here
Dear nitin
I am active trader Please make able PI on my I’d RP0187 please…
Hi Nitin,
As per your eligibility criteria, I’m an active trader. But though not able to see Pi download link. Please let us know when I can see this. It’s very annoying to wait.
Client Id: DS3538
Thanks Nitin and Zerodha.
Got my Pi link.
Thanks,
Amey
DR1916
Am i eligible to get Pi ? please look @ my profile and provide me the link ….. without charting i cant trade …. please provide me the downloading link …… And please make it free from bugs ………
ID dj9270 active member, provide link for pi
Please enable PI for my client ID DS1917
Dear Nitin,
I got an email from Zerodha that Pi will be available shortly and the icon will be in q.zerodha.com. I dont see the Pi icon yet there. Is there is a general email to all or the email is sent to select few. Please clarify
Sir this is my user id please activate PI
Thanks in advance 🙂
Sir this is my user id RR1226 please activate PI
Thanks in advance 🙂
we like the reason why zerodha keep segment on yours client.we are confuse why we are her with zerodha.its not good waiting for long and again making client segment active- inactive,I think its not necessary you keep us somewhere farther
नितिन प्लीज
पाय दो या मत दो पर काम से काम हेईकन अशी चार्ट्स तो ज़ेरोदा ट्रेडर पर चालू करो मैं सिर्फ हैकेन अशी चार्ट्स फेलो करता हूँ
१/४ ट्रेडिंग कैपिटल लॉस कर चूका हू ज़ेरोधा पर अकाउंट खोलनेका मकसद सिर्फ हैकेन चार्ट्स था
अगर ट्रेडर लॉस करने लगा तो कोई फरक नहीं पड़ता की ब्रोकरेज कम रहा तो भी
हम लोग सर्वाइव नहीं करेंगे तो आप कहा से कमाओगे
Hi Nitin,
I got an email from Zerodha that Pi will be available shortly and the icon will be in q.zerodha.com. I dont see the Pi icon yet there. I am using the PI beta please enable the new release so that i can trade using PI.
I am a active user and have generated more than rupee 300 brokerage….
Client Code:RR0650
Request you please activate my code in PI , still the status showing as pending.. i am an active trader.
nithin ji
please post latest updates, half of the day has gone.
hi nitin,
please let us know if pi is working fine for those client whom you have licensed today,so that we could expect further release.
All the Best Nitin. I really hope you will release PI very soon to us to trade on most advanced trading platform.
Hi Nitin,
Please activate PI for my user id RC 0547; i am active member generating more than required brokerage.
Chethan Rai
Hi Nitin,
Please start Part 3 of this PI feedback and overview thread. User who have got access to latest (final) beta can share their experiences for the benefit of others. We would like to hear more about Final PI beta.
Here you go: http://zerodha.com/z-connect/zerodha/bulletin-latest-at-zerodha/pi-final-beta-release
finally gets link on my q hope gets pi too early thanks zerodha and thanks nitin
Nitin,
Got the link and Pi Status : Pending activation
Do we still need the 48 hour period to wait, it is getting exciting at this point and I really want to get my hands on this awesome software, please enable and bump it up
on my login ID as per your records
Thanks for all your efforts.
Hi Nitin,
Is there any link to see the new video. Please post in Z-Connect for General View!!!!
Check this: http://zerodha.com/z-connect/zerodha/bulletin-latest-at-zerodha/pi-final-beta-release, we will have video for each section soon.
‘Access pending activation’. Things are falling into place. It has been pretty rough for you .Hopefully the going will be a lot smoother from now on. Congratulations!
Here comes one more criteria from Mr. Nitin.
New criteria to have Pi (or for being considered as an active trader)—-minimum Rs. 10,000 in your account.
I got Pi link in my Q but with the following message:-
“We are allowing access to only active traders as of now. Make sure to have atleast Rs 10,000 in either your equity or commodity account to qualify as an active trader.”
One more thing Nitin Ji,
Suppose at present the balance in my account is Rs. 10000. So as per your criteria I can download and use Pi.
After one month while trading I lost Rs.4000 and my balance get reduced to
Rs 6000. So in that condition can I use Pi with Rs 6000 in my account.
Please reply Nitin Ji
Dhirendra, very soon we will have the final release. We still aren’t fixed on a condition, but as long as you are trading with us, we will ensure that you get this for free. We just want to be sure, that people don’t use this with us and trade somewhere else.
This Rs 10,000 was by popular requests, there are many active clients of ours who might be trading once or twice a month for the last 3 years. Hence we decided on an account value of Rs 10,000.
Got the link for Pi and registered for it. Shd be up and running in a day or two.
Have attached the screenshot.
Rather than one size fits all strategy, I hope Zerodha has a few options for weeding out dormant/inactive, resource hogging account .
Example:
1. Rs 300 adjustable towards brokerage
2. X Amount as average balance
3. Loyalty Points or
4. Others strategies
Sticking only to charging monthly fee may be a high risk strategy since may spoil Brand Zerodha.
Good to always give 4 or 5 options and let the dormant accounts weed themselves out!
Please do not misunderstand my comment since I do not want to teach you how to run a business that you have built .
Bala, we want to keep the business simple. It has worked well for us until now. Rs 10,000 in the trading account covers most of our active clients. But yeah, before we roll out the final release, we will think of adding another option to determine active traders.
Nithin,
if a client has minimum rs.10000 in his trading account then still he has to pay rs.300 or not??
No not required.
thats really a nice decision taken by you as putting rs.10000 in trading is convienent for the trader rather than giving rs.300.
nice 🙂
Thank you …. 🙂 …. U have listen to us …. relief …. 🙂
“Active client for us is anyone who has atleast Rs 10,000 (including cash + Option premium + margin blocked) in either the equity or commodity account with us.”
I think this criteria will cover the eligibility criteria for active traders ….. 🙂 …. Thank you again ….. I will reiterate again again ….. you are one hell of a CEO /LEADER 🙂 …. keep it up ….. GOD BLESS YOU AND UR BUSINESS …..
Nithinji,
Please activate the PI link to my account RR3277.My account meets all the criteria required for the activation of PI.
Waiting eagerly for the activation .
Thank you in advance.
Do read this
DS3412 if am I active trader for enable Pi
Then Release Please.
Thanks ZERODHA TEAM.
Well predicted the release of Jan 14 2015 as PI link given today it will be activated only on 14th Jan 2015 I will swith to other broker if any glich single comes in picture of zerodha trading in this new terminal.
Nithin,
i am new into zerodha as my account is recently opened,so i think i am inactive trader for zerodha.as you said that “Omnesys/Reuters the vendors of NEST have stopped supporting Nest Plus, and hence the previous version is not available. We will start giving out Pi to everyone very soon.”
so if my zerodha trader will stop working and i want to trade then how can i trade.?
and you will charge rs.300 for pi software for inactive trader.if you charge firstly rs. 300 for pi software and if in the end the brokerage generated is more than rs.300 then will you refund the money?
We don’t plan to charge anything for Pi, whatever you pay will get adjusted for brokerage. For now we have decided to remove that Rs 300 condition, we have decided to give it to anyone with Rs 10000 in their account. Check this post.
“whatever you pay will get adjusted for the brokerage-nithin kamath” then your brokerage is still rs.40(buying and selling) or it will be now in pi like 45 or 50?? is it still same brokerage like rs.20 per executed order in the pi??
Can u give us the link to the new video of pi !!!
Can you check this, no video as such: http://zerodha.com/z-connect/zerodha/bulletin-latest-at-zerodha/pi-final-beta-release
if i will deposit rs.10000 then can i put a request for Pi software?
Yes.
dear Nithin,
Is there any way to calculate the margin required for BO&CO without going to your website and calculating there, i dont trade myself as i am using your paltform to trade my clients.its a very good facility to provide high leverage.can we calculate margin manually using normal calculator,so that i can provide this BO&CO facility to my clients?
If there is any way to calculate the margin required using bo&co,i will be very thankful to you.
if there is no such way right now,then its a suggestion that please work on it also.
Not possible right now other than going to our webpage.
nithin,
can i get some other facility beside this refrral program as i have many clients who dont have time to operate themselves thats i do their trading.so i want to expand my business and i wanna expand your business too.
now i am looking for long term business relationship with your company.
just i am looking for is good facilty if someone is using your platform for business purpose.
thanks!
Akash, as per SEBI rules, you are not allowed to trade on behalf of another person without the mandatory licenses. At Zerodha we don’t allow anyone access to terminals where they can trade on behalf of another person. Check this: http://tradingqna.com/780/trader-dealer-terminal-portfolio-management-what-right-about
Sir,no other person is accesing the terminal.i am the only one who is accesing your terminal.like a normal trader i am doing trading.i am thinking to deposit more money today in my trading account using cheque. i assure you and your company that i will take any wrong step.
just as a simply trader i am doing trading?
they dont have any trading account.its my account only and i am trading as a normal trader.
if above the things i am doing wrong,then find some solution for it and guide me properly.i also want stand in the stock market.
Aksash,
I thought you asked me, if there is a way to trade on other people’s account. There is a way to do it, using what is called as dealer terminals. But we don’t allow it at Zerodha as it is not legal to do portfolio management without a license.
If you have raised money and trading with it, there is no issues with it at all. But here is the thing, you seem like a fresher and the best way to start is by trading only on what you can afford to loose. Don’t borrow money, unless you are able to first make money yourself consistently for atleast 6 months to a year.
Akash*
thanks for your suggestion nithin,but i am not totally fresher.as firstly i had account with Angel broking i made people trade through me using angel broking.i have already raised some money,i am not trading here properly because i want to be perfect in zerodha.i have some other accounts also.
anyways i got your answer that i can do trading here,thanks for your help!
hi,
will holdings value(demat) also count in 10000?
good luck for your team.:)
No aditya, not for the beta release. But we might start using the holdings value with our final release.
Mr nithin. Thanks for taking a great decision of keeping Pi free. Everyone will fulfill the criteria of 10000 Rs. BE READY TO OPEN THE LAKHS OF ACOUNTS IN 2015. PLEASE ACCEPT MY ADWANCE GREETINGS FOR MAKING ZERODHA THE NO ONE INDIAN STOCK MARKET BROKING FIRM.
Regards,
Fazlur Rehman
I believe the decision to make PI available at the cost of 300-500 rs per month or a deposit of 10000 rs is very decent.. Well, everyone needs to understand that there are no free lunches in this world and if PI is that good as it boasts to be the India’s most advance trading platform, no one would like to see it slipped from there hands just for 300 Rs that too when it can be adjusted against brokerage.. I would like to see PI growing mature, bug free and really a game changer platform and this is only possible when it runs loss free. ..
@Nishant no free lunches we are paying brokerage for trading & getting services from zerodha neither zerodha give brokerage free services even for a day. And the software part is analysis & trading but for exchange its just an order nothing more than that.
we would have switched to other brokers I am active trader for 5 Broking firms.
If they charge extra also i will switch to discounted brokers.
Thats what i said.. no free lunches.. and to have pi then fulfil few conditions..
I am impressed that You are active with 5 brokerage firms.. you must be the Warren buffet of India.. don’t mind .. just kidding…
Dear nitin
Thanks ZERODHA for providing awaiting PI
.
@Nitin
Even after sending request to activate PI & with minimum criteria your support team has not activate the field highlighted in q.zerodha.com I can see Pi the icon to activate is being freezed.
Please provide me the link to activate it My Client id DR0875
Ravi, we are giving out in batches. Checking on why your link to activate is frozen.
nithin,
same problem is coming in my account also.after the market hours i also tried to request for getting pi beta access.when i click on “Get pi beta access” button.its not doing anything.
Akash, you need to have 10k in your account to be able to place the request for Pi.
Hi Nithin
I have Rs 45000+ in my account and Equity Holdings worth Rs.42000 Not able to make rquest in ZERODHA Q since the request buttons is not opening.Kindly look in the matter.
NAME G.Chandra Mohan
Client ID DC0024
Chandra, we are presently releasing this to people with cash + margin more than Rs 10,000. Your account has holdings, but not cash. Hence you are not able to click on the link.
Hi Nithin
I have transferred Rs 450000 through Zerodha gate way in the morning
it is not reflected in the Zerodha Q but the ZERODHA TRADER is reflecting the amount. Please reconcile and do the needful.
amount should read as RS 45,000 . Sorry for the typo
chandra mohan
Chandra, Q gets updated only end of day. You will be able to put that request by today evening.
I have requested Pi in BO on 12/01/2015. still request is pending. please do the needful asap.
Nitin,
Though i am eligible in all the criteria, and having message since last 72 hrs that link to pi will be activated in 48 hrs. no actions at your end. also there is no request button seen in q.zerodha. only there is message that your link to pi will be activated in 48 hrs. do need full
DJ9270
Today evening we will be giving out the release to over 500 people, we have been adding slowly for the last two days.
Nitin,
more than one lac rs. balalce since last 3 years, more than 3000 rs monthly brokerage, message since last 72 hrs that your pi link will be activated within 48 hrs and there is no action at your end, no link for pi download. seems some thing fissy nitin.
DJ9270
I see that you are already enabled today. can you check now on Q.
Hi Nithin
I have transferred Rs 45,000 through Zerodha gate way in the morning
it is not reflected in the Zerodha Q but the ZERODHA TRADER is reflecting the amount. Please reconcile and do the needful.
¶
Hi Nitin
My ID DO0042. I have activated zerodha PI in zerodha q two days before but still showing activation status as pending. As Mr. Nitin said minimum balance in account should be 10,000 but i have more than 1 Lakh in my trading account and apart from this i am doing Equity and commodity intraday trading daily generating brokerage at least Rs. 50 per day for zerodha. So please activate the Pi by today or tomorrow else surely switch my trading account to some other better broking concern.
My name D.Omprakash
phone: 9566068331
Id: DO0042
Hi Nitin
My ID DO0042. I have activated zerodha PI in zerodha q two days before but still showing activation status as pending. As Mr. Nitin said minimum balance in account should be 10,000 but i have more than 1 Lakh in my trading account and apart from this i am doing Equity and commodity intraday trading daily generating brokerage at least Rs. 50 per day for zerodha. So please activate the Pi by today or tomorrow else surely switch my trading account to some other better broking concern.
My name D.Omprakash
phone: 9566068331
Id: DO0042
Dear Nitin,
It is really long time I am waiting for the pi. Kindly actvate the “GET BETA PI ACCESS”.
Thanks
M.Anantha Raman
Dear Nitin,
It is really long time I am waiting for the pi. Kindly actvate the “GET BETA PI ACCESS”.
Thanks
M.Anantha Raman ID: RA2465
Nithin,
my account was opened through delhi branch so future&option stamp duty charges must be 0.002% but they are charging me rs.50,???
client id:-da2880 .. you can check my jan. 7 contract note in which i have buyed and sold same day (voltas f&o future). please take immediate action to solve this problem.
Dear Nitin,
I have found pi link on my Q but still not activate.pleased make me enable trade on pi on my I’d RC0258.i Iove pi I like trade on pi.
With thanks
Nithin,
Sir, as per the commitment given Mr. Raj Gaur Of Delhi Branch,his contact no. is 9310092020,8049693030.
firstly i send the documents to delhi branch then they forwarded the documents for account opening to your head office, at that time when account was not opened,i called your headoffice that i dont wanna open an account,immediately i got a call from “Raj Gaur” and he convinced me and i said okay i wanna open an account.”AT THAT TIME HE TOLD ME THAT MY STAMP DUTY WILL BE CHARGED OF DELHI I.E 0.002% FOR FUTURE AND OPTION” BUT NOW I HAVE SEEN THAT MY STAMP DUTY IS CHARGED RS. 50 ON THE STOCKS THAT I HAVE BUYED AND SOLD AT THAT DAY ONLY ON 7/1/2015. “HE SAID THAT DONT WORRY STAMP AAPKO DELHI KA HEE LGEGA BUS ACCOUNT OPEN KRWAVIYE”
“Sir ab ye puchna hai aapse agr “raj gaur ji” ne kaha tha stamp duty aapko 0.002%lgega toh ab jada kyu lg raha hai”
aap aise logo ke khilaf action kyu nhi leta jisse aapke client kharab ho”please tell me sir??
Akash, Raj assumed that you are from delhi. Stamp duty in Delhi is 0.002%. Since we have no setup in Punjab, we charge stamp as per our head office (Karnataka which is 0.01%, but a max of Rs 50 per day). Karnataka stamp is actually a boon for active traders. The stamp duty per day will never exceed Rs 50, whereas in Delhi it will Rs 200 for every crore. We will take action against Raj for not informing you correctly.
@nithin:
no sir he knew that i am from punjab, i told him at that time that about this stamp duty,but he simply said” wo muj pe chor do,aap bus apna account open krwaiye”
aaj mr.raj gaur ji se phone pr baat pr maine unko bola ki stamp duty toh delhi ki nhi lgi jaisa ki aapne bola tha toh kehne lge” haa wo galti hogye merese”
sir,ab aap khud btaye aapke liye ek ek client matter krta hai yaa nhi??aapke liye ek ek client matter krta hai for growing the business more.uss bande ne commitment krke tod diya
all i want is to take strict action against him if client is saying truly then from my point of you you must take strict action agianst him
thanks!
@nithin
aur rahi baat business ki toh apne bola ki “this is illegal to operate someone trading account” so you have given me good advice.
i talked to “Mr. Raj gaur” about this,his views are:- “aap bs clients reffral karo,maine bola ki mere paas kuch aise clients hai jinke paas time nhi hota ” toh wo bole “aap chinta mat kro aap clients reffer kriye mai aap unka trading account through trading krdena koi problem nhi aayegi ” sath mei bole ki ye baat aap upper mat btana”
“aur bole company ke andar abhi andar hee baat chl rahi hai ki “jaise 50000 mei 200000 ki delivery utha sakte ho pr thoda sa time lg sakta hai pr jaldi hee hojayega toh aap ko mai uss ke baare mei bhi btadunga” “bs clients reffer kriye”
all the above statement is true as per conversation with him..if above the statement went wrong..i am liable for it!
thanks!
Thanks for letting us know, we will take action on this asap.
thanks For your Support nithin!
Hello Nithin,
While we wait for the release of the final beta, would appreciate if you could let us know how the limited release has fared thus far. Am sure most of the traders with Zerodha are as eager as I am to know how ‘Pi’ has done in the last two days. Additionally, it will also help set the right timeline expectations for those of us who await ‘Pi’ to recommence trading.
Looking forward to your response,
Best,
Senthil
(DS2929)
Senthil, it has been going well thus far. Like usual, getting new feature requests, but most of what we have seems to be working well. If tomorrow goes okay, we will have 1000 licenses released by eod tomm.
how should i send the request ?
loged in Q , and clicked on PI icon . is that it ?
Is it possible to provide “Busket Order” for “Normal” and “After Market Hour” in Pi ? It will be very helpful to me. Thanks in advance.
After market order is available, check under orders (shortcut key: Ctrl + F1)
Yes, “After Market Hour order” is available. I was asking for “After Market Basket order”.
@ NItin
Zerodha became crorepathi with actual cash holding for 2 days.
Due to there terminal activation Sound goods for business people.
10000*50000 active clients 45 crore rupees in a day hard cash in there account.
Can trade & earn very quick money there cost of PI recovered in 1 day trade.
Turnover & the hard cash matches.
@Trader
Money management is easy from this So think about the banks holding cash & gave plastic card all salary directs to bank. 🙂
Mr Nithin
Happy Shankaranthi Please give us our long awaited gift today by actvating Pi link.
Thanks
RA 2465
We were able to add all the additional load with the market bump very well, Pi worked very well today. We will enable for everyone else today after market closing.
Happy Sankranthi.
Wow!!! thats gr8 nithin….
Hey Nithin,
I guess options Greek Calculator has not been added to this update.. When is it expected to be part of software?? Also, in Fibonacci analysis do add Extensions and Projections… It will be very helpful for target setting..
Regards,
Ankit.
Ankit, we will add new features once we have the final release of Pi.
Nithin and Zerodha Family ,
Wish you all a very Happy Sankranthi and New Year ( -15 day old) !!
I got the Pi enabled and started testing and playing around, I do like it very much.
I never checked my Q account so many times logging in logging out till I saw the link was enabled.
PI is advanced and easy to understand.
I have very few basic ASKs at this time to make it much more robust and useful to be moving out of from the Nestplus.
How should I report about all the requirements to be added for this software?
What is the Final release of the Software date?
I am documenting with screen shots so that it would be helpful to all traders if you implement it before final release.
Not a major rework, but small tid bit changes in and around.
Deepak, send this as an email to [email protected] and [email protected]
Thanks
Installed pi.half an hour ago. everything fine. perfect software. darwas box. linear regression. everything is ok.
but where I can change time frame of chart?. for example i want to change the same chart from 1 minute to 5 minute. How can I do it?. and even being an expert in software and a hacker unable to view all windows together in one frame. for eg. market watch and charts in one view. i seen it in the video.. but not find a link or clickable area to make everything in one frame. please help.?
Girija, you will have to open a chart with a different time frame. You can’t change the same to another one. To drag and drop windows in one frame, I have given a link to the video in the post above(go to min 6 and start watching). You need to hold the tab, drag and drop to wherever you want it to be placed.
Sir
Thank you . it is working fine.
How to load multiple workspaces simultaneously in Pi? Currently we can load only 1 workspace at a time.
I also researching on that. any way one solution connect your laptop(if you are using pc please forgive me) to a monitor.extend it. then pi , view popup active window . move to extended desktop. then you can view.
Peter
You can just arrange all of this within the main window itself, having it all popped out on a single monitor seems tricky.
3rd weekend of this month approaching. When is the official release of PI ?
Need to go when i type the stock name in market watch from one stock to another. instead of search from file menu. please note down for final release.
Final release will be soon, but we have put out the final beta: http://zerodha.com/z-connect/zerodha/bulletin-latest-at-zerodha/pi-final-beta-release
Nithin
What is the system requirement for Pi. My desk top has only 1gb Ram & dual core is it enough for Pi ?
Thanks
There is any script to see Hi / low breaking stocks ? (image)
Hi Nithin,
How do I save the preferences in PI? Like I rearranged the columns in Admin position and want the same layout to be shown every time when I log in. its not feasible to every day rearrange/add remove columns. Please help on this.
Thanks,
Harshit
Nitin,
You had promised that we will get Pi by 15th night. But till 17th we have NOT got it. Kindly see it to it that we get our PI by this weekend at least.
Regards
We have given it to everyone, Check this If you had put a request on 16th, you will get it in a little while.
Hi Nithin
still alerts are not working and the root cause I think is that the alert linked chart which is opening automatically when we start the alert is not getting data automatically—it just freezes after opening—–I told this to siva, but he is saying why do you need the alert chart!!!!
He is not patient like you to listen and understand things. as per me the simple ligic is that when alert chart will not get data aotomatically –then how can it does its function properly???
I had lot of hopes to see at least the basic things like alerts and scanners to be perfect in the final beta release (becsuse these two aspects only primarily makes PI distinctive from other softwares available in Indian market freely to the traders), but sadly no improvements at all in these two aspects.
Hope to listen from you with things got done and dusted!!!
Cheers!!!
Santosh
Hi Nitin,
Congratulations on the launch of Pi. Though there are so many discount brokers in the market but zerodha is the one with the edge. Though I am having som issues with Pi regarding hang ups and restart, I am sure they would get resolved with the launch of final version.
Some suggstions:
1) When you keep your pointer to a candle in chart, It should show High,Low, close and open values along with time stamp. This is a big let down as I need to keep guessing the values.
2) In the technical indicators drop down, there is no option of going to the indicator by pressing the first alphabet, so you need to keep pressing down the down arrow.
I could think of only these two as of now which means you have done a good job 🙂
Thanks
Saurabh, can you send snapshots of hangups that you faced and when this happened to [email protected] and [email protected]. Will help us fix this.
1. Left click and hover over the candle, you can see the OHLC
2. Yep, working on it.
Hi Nithin,
I will surely send the snapshots if I encounter the same problem. There was some problem in broadcast and hence the broadcast button was red that time.
Anyways, on point no. 1, I do not get the OLHC data even when I hover on the candles. Dont know what is the problem here..I should get in touch with the tech team I guess.
Regards,
Saurabh
Left click and hover, yeah send an email to [email protected]
hi nitin i dont have 10000 in my account as of now but i would have generated atleast 300 brokerage in a month.will there be any possibilty of getting pi or you are planning to release it for everyone some time soon.
Regards,
DA2794
We will have it enabled for you tomorrow Amit